Proposal: 88 swap- Kane for Nylander++

[StatsNightHeroes]

If Chicago falls apart this season and Kane decides maybe he wouldn’t mind moving on to chase another cup or two while he’s still a great player.

Chicago gets Nylander, 1st in 2021 and Rodion Amirov or Liljgren.

Leafs get Kane retained to 50%

Obviously dependent on Kane agreeing to go to Toronto because of his NMC.

Chicago gets more control with Nylander and a younger player who could step into Kane’s role, even if he isn’t that close to Kane’s caliber at this stage of their careers. They also get 1 promising 2020 first round pick in Amirov. And the Leafs hopefully late 2021 first round pick.

Leafs get an experienced winner and one of the best playmakers of his generation. They also get some additional cap space to accommodate some internal raises on guys like Hyman and Freddy.

Click to read more...

 

[Ledge And Dairy]

There are much better teams to chase a cup on than Toronto. No way Chicago eats 50% of his contract anyways

 

[Buzzman17]

There are much better teams to chase a cup on than Toronto. No way Chicago eats 50% of his contract anyways

Not this year

 

[StatsNightHeroes]

There are much better teams to chase a cup on than Toronto. No way Chicago eats 50% of his contract anyways

It’s not a desperation cup chase for Kane, if he likes his fit there for 2 and a half years more than he likes Chicago it makes sense. Gets to play with Marner and JT, two other high skill London nights alumni and fellow American star in Matthews.

Maybe there are other contenders who can swing a deal who he thinks have a better chance to win but the team has to like the package too.

Chicago is only eating the 50% for 2 more years. Given Toews situation, Keith and Seabrooks age and Kane’s own quickly approaching UFA they might really like the idea of adding 3+ first round picks value in guys all under the age of 25.

 

[Brobust]

Toronto says no.

 

[WTFMAN99]

Leafs would pass, too many assets out the door.

 

[Jimmy Firecracker]

Yeah no thanks. If Leafs are looking to add a winger it won't be at the expense of a roster player, that would defeat the purpose.

 

[peconcan]

No thanks, would Kane even want to come here anyway? Assume he has a NMC??

 

[JT Kreider]

Kane would never

 

[Pile]

The thought of Kane in a Maple Leaf sweater disgusts me

 

[TheKrebsCycle]

Too high a price to pay. Kane is a stud but is getting up there. Elc contributors like Robertson/Sandin/Amirov/Lil are key to balancing the capped out roster.

 

[Unbiased Fan]

From a leafs POV id do this. Kindve reminds me of the Demar Derozen+++For Kawhi trade. Look how that turned out.

 

[Ledge And Dairy]

It’s not a desperation cup chase for Kane, if he likes his fit there for 2 and a half years more than he likes Chicago it makes sense. Gets to play with Marner and JT, two other high skill London nights alumni and fellow American star in Matthews.

Maybe there are other contenders who can swing a deal who he thinks have a better chance to win but the team has to like the package too.

Chicago is only eating the 50% for 2 more years. Given Toews situation, Keith and Seabrooks age and Kane’s own quickly approaching UFA they might really like the idea of adding 3+ first round picks value in guys all under the age of 25.

I feel like you are trying to justify something that would fundamentally flawed and extremely unrealistic

 

[Adele Dazeem]

The difference between Nylander and Kane isn't that big at this point in time

 

[Mrfenn92]

As a hawks fan think I’m saying yes

 

[Michael HOMERUNing]

The difference between Nylander and Kane isn't that big at this point in time

It's pretty big. But if the Leafs are moving Nylander I would want a d-man back

Edit: It's a top 3 winger vs a top 30 one

 

[StatsNightHeroes]

I feel like you are trying to justify something that would fundamentally flawed and extremely unrealistic

I’m not saying it’s the most likely trade but it’s a big one I think makes sense for both teams and possibly the player with the NMC. Can’t remember if Willy has a modified NTC this year but the chance to play with his brother and be the go to guy on the PP might be enough incentive.

 

[Ledge And Dairy]

I’m not saying it’s the most likely trade but it’s a big one I think makes sense for both teams and possibly the player with the NMC. Can’t remember if Willy has a modified NTC this year but the chance to play with his brother and be the go to guy on the PP might be enough incentive.

When was the last time a team retained 50% on a multi year contract that was over 6M let alone over 10M? Kane's not going to waive to Canada anyways

 

[A1LeafNation]

LOL fk no.

 

[Leafs87]

No way. The leafs need their 1st to gain ELC contributors and same with Lil/Amirov. This one just doesn’t make sense. Also Nylander plays his role well. He may not be everyone’s ideal player but he’s a hell of an offensive winger

 

[StatsNightHeroes]

When was the last time a team retained 50% on a multi year contract that was over 6M let alone over 10M? Kane's not going to waive to Canada anyways

I think the flat cap situation will change the way a lot teams look at things. If Chicago’s management has any sense they know their team isn’t anywhere close to completing. Why not retain for 2 years where you know you are rebuilding if you are getting three young cost controlled pieces.

I’m sure some other teams would be interested but how many can make a package like that and it still be worth it for them?

Kane would be very close to home and only has two seasons left on his deal after this. Definitely worse places he could play the next two years...

 

[DFF]

The difference between Nylander and Kane isn't that big at this point in time

Lol it's huge

 

[Esq]

The difference between Nylander and Kane isn't that big at this point in time

Why, does Nylander have bankruptcy issues too?

 

[t0nedeff]

The difference between Nylander and Kane isn't that big at this point in time

about 30 points since the start of last year I'd say thats a fairly big difference.

 

[TSA0402]

For Kane at 50%, Hawks get Nylander plus another very good asset. For the record a late 1st is not a very good asset.