Explains the lack of top talent coming from la belle provinceWhat?!? That's just ******ed.
Explains the lack of top talent coming from la belle provinceWhat?!? That's just ******ed.
About Joseph, I was reffering to the Yotes willing to part away with him in a trade... Also, he failed to make team Canada's squad as a 19 yrs old in his D+2 season, a left side that was wide open... Watched him a couple of times, including the Subway challenge where he failed to impress one more time, was pretty vanilla to say the least...Exactly what I thought, bad fate. Joseph was traded to a contender in Drummond, just like Dobson was in Rouyn. Nothing wrong with that. Also nothing wrong with the fact that he didn't make Team Canada for WJC as a 18 year old. Of course he's not an elite tier prospect à la Dobson or Byram, but he has very good chances to make it in the NHL.
Lauzon was a 7th defenseman on the best team in the NHL as a 21 year old. What. A. Scrub.
I'm not saying these will all turn out to be all-stars, but most of them will have a career. If you want to spew your hate, go ahead, but be ready for counter-arguments.
In your initial enumeration, you forgot two of the best young offensive defensemen in the NHL in Chabot and Girard. Québec's defense could challenge any country not named Canada in terms of depth and quality. The province is not the hockey development hotbed it used for many factors including lack of quality coaching. But it's still not too shabby.
About Joseph, I was reffering to the Yotes willing to part away with him in a trade... Also, he failed to make team Canada's squad as a 19 yrs old in his D+2 season, a left side that was wide open... Watched him a couple of times, including the Subway challenge where he failed to impress one more time, was pretty vanilla to say the least...
Chabot is great, never said otherwise, Girard is a nice offensive talent but remains average to below average defensively... You have to think the Avalanche will move him at some point since they have both Byram and Makar on the left side, unless they move Girard on the right side but it doesnt look good about it... Lauzon, we will see, not established yet and no real trait of dominance either...
No way the Q can challenge the OHL and WHL, even less Sweden and probably not even Finland when it comes to develop defensemen, thats not even close... Im not a hater, Im only an observer made in Quebec too, I watch those kids and try to have an objective look regardless where they come from, actually the Q compares more to Russia than anything else when it comes to defensemen...
Saying he was put in a trade for Kessel only add to my personal observation that Joseph isnt that good of a prospect, I would call him a B prospect right now, maybe he will have an impressive developmental curve, thats always a possibility, but thats pretty unlikely at this point IMO.Except Makar is a RHD. Your argument for Joseph is flawed. Did anybody rip apart Suzuki because he was traded? What if Arizona liked Joseph, but preferred Kessel?
Hi Made this little scouting report on Norlinder. Hope you guys enjoy !
Hi Made this little scouting report on Norlinder. Hope you guys enjoy !
That's some incredible praise. "I want him to improve all phases of his game, and he should be a leading defender both with Modo Hockey and in the Allsvenskan. I would be extremely surprised if he doesn’t become one of the defensive leaders on the World Junior Championship team, too."Coach Björn Hellkvist: Mattias Norlinder "has the whole package"
The fact that he didn’t spend the full year with the senior team could be used as a strike against the young defender, but Coach Hellkvist clearly explains that it was a conscious decision of the coaching staff.
“Very early last season, it was evident that he was too good for the Juniors. We only waited for the right moment to bring him into the senior team so it wouldn’t backfire and hurt his development.”
His coach is very high on him and thinks he could be in the NHL by next year (although I will admit the quote could be interpreted as him being ready to come over too).
I hope he one ups Romanov and becomes another wtf WJC MVP .
Hi Made this little scouting report on Norlinder. Hope you guys enjoy !
Hi Made this little scouting report on Norlinder. Hope you guys enjoy !
I love watching him. But somehow, he is Claude Julien's worst nightmare. Yet, great pick. You pick talent. You don't pick because of the coach he has. Players will be there. Coaches are replaceable.
But he is always moving. So dynamic. Love him. I don't think that this pick was and will be questioned.
He seems fine defensively though, no? I'd think Struble would give CJ more fits than Norlinder imo.
Coach Björn Hellkvist: Mattias Norlinder "has the whole package"
The fact that he didn’t spend the full year with the senior team could be used as a strike against the young defender, but Coach Hellkvist clearly explains that it was a conscious decision of the coaching staff.
“Very early last season, it was evident that he was too good for the Juniors. We only waited for the right moment to bring him into the senior team so it wouldn’t backfire and hurt his development.”
His coach is very high on him and thinks he could be in the NHL by next year (although I will admit the quote could be interpreted as him being ready to come over too).
Makar Is RdAbout Joseph, I was reffering to the Yotes willing to part away with him in a trade... Also, he failed to make team Canada's squad as a 19 yrs old in his D+2 season, a left side that was wide open... Watched him a couple of times, including the Subway challenge where he failed to impress one more time, was pretty vanilla to say the least...
Chabot is great, never said otherwise, Girard is a nice offensive talent but remains average to below average defensively... You have to think the Avalanche will move him at some point since they have both Byram and Makar on the left side, unless they move Girard on the right side but it doesnt look good about it... Lauzon, we will see, not established yet and no real trait of dominance either...
No way the Q can challenge the OHL and WHL, even less Sweden and probably not even Finland when it comes to develop defensemen, thats not even close... Im not a hater, Im only an observer made in Quebec too, I watch those kids and try to have an objective look regardless where they come from, actually the Q compares more to Russia than anything else when it comes to defensemen...
This is how I wanted to handle Kotkaniemi last year. Not upset that he made the NHL but I think the only reason he made it was cause our center depth was ****ty. All he had to do was beat out Pleky, DLR, and Peca. For a talented 18 year old kid who plays the center game the right way, it was not that difficult. I prefer more patience and I would of liked for him to dominate a development league prior to the NHL. Not worried about what we actually did but it's not my personal strategy
Caufield, Struble, and Norlinder look like 3 very good picks. Did the Habs hit again in the 2nd round? That would be 3 drafts in a row and very impressive if we did. Lets see how these 3 look at the half way point of next season. Would be nice to see all 3 in the WJC!
Pitlick and Fairbrother also looking good. That's 5 so far. I look forwardcto hearing more about the Russian and the goalie.
I hear good things about Pitlick but I'm not high on Fairbrother (not yet anyways). I would love surprises in the later round but not expecting it. My eyes are on Caufield, Struble, Norlinder and Pitlick. As far as the other guys, it's very possible some can surprise and it's too dam hard to tell right now.
My excitnent for Caufield and Struble are largely based on what the scouts say, but also seeing them at development camp. I was impressed with Pitlick and Fairbrother at development canp. With Norlinder it's all about the recent interview with his coach.
I have neither seen nor heard anything about the goalie or the russian with the long name. So they're both complete unknowns to me. Don't even have any speculation and hearsay on them, unlike the others...