In his OHL draft year, he registered 114 points in 71 games (as well as 14 in seven at the year-end OHL Cup to play himself onto the tournament all-star team), good for third in the GTHL behind Wright and Othmann, the eventual first and second picks in the 2019 OHL draft.
Throughout that year, the Kitchener Rangers took a keen interest in him, ranking him among their top five or six skaters in the draft from the first tournament of his minor midget season right through to the OHL Cup.
“We just really liked his blend of hockey sense, his compete, and his skill level,” said Rangers general manager and head coach Mike McKenzie. “He’s a dual threat. He can score, he’s got a really good shot, but he can also make plays and set guys up. He was the catalyst of that team offensively. He was always the guy.”
They eventually picked him 13th, even though his Red Wings head coach Angelo Catenaro says there were “at least seven teams that would have taken him before that” after his people and his agency, Octagon, made their desire to be in Kitchener (closer to home) clear.
“There were teams that were ready to take him in the top five,” Catenaro said.
In his rookie season in Kitchener, Pinelli earned a top role out of training camp and was quickly slotted onto the Rangers’ first line (he played the majority of his first year, on a talented Kitchener team which won 40 of 63 games, in the Rangers’ top six). When the year was done, he’d produced once more at the top of his age group, with 41 points in 59 games, third among under-17 players behind only 2022 prospect Wright (60 points) and 2021 prospect Mason McTavish (42 points).