I think Cogliano is under-rated around here.
Still really good in the defensive and neutral zones. Useless is the offensive zone, but at least Bowness knows that. Comeau still gets the minutes of a 2-way winger rather then a one dimensional defender.
I also think Cogliano is still a really good skater and hasn't been hit by father time quite is much over the past year. Comeau was never fast, but it's bordering on glacier territory. I think he'll be unplayable this time next year.
I think any complaints on Cogliano and Comeau get magnified because of their contracts.
The top teams in the NHL have realized it's stupid to hand 2-3M contracts to bottom 6 talent. The talent pool is big enough where you can pinch pennies and sign FAs for cheap to play these roles- or you graduate players from your farm.