I was more surprised by Heath Bell. The guy had two good years. At least Putz was solid for a long time, but he wasn’t exceptional by any means.
I’ve always held that average offensive players do not belong in the Hall unless they have Ozzie Smith level greatness at defense. Vizquel wasn’t that good defensively and Ozzie was significantly better offensively than Vizquel offensively too.
There are worse humans than Schilling in the Hall of Fame. Schilling belongs despite how much of a loudmouth buffoon the guy is.