The Athletic - Boston 2020 ‘Salary Cap Era’ NHL Franchise Rankings

Fenway

HF Bookie and Bruins Historian
Sponsor
Sep 26, 2007
68,896
99,340
Cambridge, MA
Here’s how this scoring system works to rank every NHL franchise since the salary cap was implemented before the 2005-06 season:

Winning the Stanley Cup (SC): 11 points
Losing in the Stanley Cup Final (SCF): 5 points
Losing in the conference final (CF): 3 points
Making the playoffs: 1 point

There’s no double-dipping, so if a team wins the Stanley Cup in a given year, they also don’t get the point for making the playoffs. It’s weighted in favor of major success. A team could make the playoffs every single year and have just four more points than a team that won a single Stanley Cup and missed the playoffs every other season. I mean, that’s what we’re doing here. Measuring champions. And then, or course, dividing them into tiers.

Let’s dive in.

Tier 1: The Heavyweights

1. Pittsburgh Penguins

Total: 50

2. Chicago Blackhawks

Total: 44

3 (tied). Boston Bruins

3 (tied). Los Angeles Kings

3 (tied). Tampa Bay Lightning


Total: 29

Tier 2: The Light Heavyweights

6 (tied). Anaheim Ducks

6 (tied). Detroit Red Wings


Total: 27

8. San Jose Sharks

Total: 23

9. Washington Capitals

Total: 22

10. St. Louis Blues

Total: 21

The Athletic's 2020 'Salary Cap Era' NHL Franchise Rankings
 
  • Like
Reactions: AngryMilkcrates

The Laukomotive

Registered User
Nov 26, 2017
946
1,297
Interesting how the writer doesn't differentiate losing in the first or second round.

Here's a series win table taken from reddit.

6kp0ievni3q51.png
 

Dr Hook

It’s Called Ruins
Sponsor
Mar 9, 2005
14,084
20,842
Tyler, TX
From Craig Custance at The Athletic:


Tier 1: The Heavyweights

1. Pittsburgh Penguins

Total: 50
Sidney Crosby’s rookie season was the first season of the salary cap era and the Penguins have been the best franchise in hockey during this stretch. It bothered Crosby when the Blackhawks closed the gap with multiple Cup wins in the middle of the last decade but Pittsburgh’s answer during the Mike Sullivan era has pushed the Penguins back to the top. The Penguins even have a little breathing room. The question now becomes whether or not they can add to it as GM Jim Rutherford does everything in his power to extend the window. What a run it’s been for this franchise.
Total playoff years: 20, 19, 18, 17SC, 16SC, 15, 14, 13CF, 12, 11, 10, 09SC, 08SCF, 07
Average: 3.33 points per season

2. Chicago Blackhawks

Total: 44
The fact that the Blackhawks have one playoff appearance in the last three years and are still this far ahead of the next team is a testament to the prompt dominance of the Kane/Toews years. They arrived a little earlier than anyone expected in advancing to a conference final in 2009 and just kept on winning. Now, it’s a race to see if the young players in Chicago can develop fast enough to give those veterans another legitimate shot.
Total playoff years: 20, 17, 16, 15SC, 14CF, 13SC, 12, 11, 10SC, 09CF
Average: 2.93 points per season

3 (tied). Boston Bruins

Total: 29
The Bruins and Kings are tied here and it’s fitting. They’ve both won in the last decade with a similar DNA; physical, hard teams that featured highly skilled players who excelled on both sides of the ice. The difference is that the Bruins have a shot to add significantly to their total next season and the Kings are very much in a rebuilding mode. This coming season might be the final shot for Bruins veterans before they sink back for a moment to do what the Kings are doing now.
Total playoff years: 20, 19SCF, 18, 17, 14, 13SCF, 12, 11SC, 10, 09, 08
Average: 1.93 points per season

3 (tied). Los Angeles Kings

Total: 29
The Kings haven’t made the playoffs since 2018 and didn’t make it for the first four years of the cap era and they still are near the top of this list. That shows you just how dominant those Drew Doughty and Anze Kopitar-led teams were. And after this draft, the system will officially be reloaded. The Kings won’t be down for long.
Total playoff years: 18, 16, 14SC, 13CF, 12SC, 11, 10
Average: 1.93 points per season

3 (tied). Tampa Bay Lightning

Total: 29
Tampa’s previous Cup was followed by the lockout that led to the salary cap. Now, after knocking on the door for years, the Lightning have jumped up these standings. And they’re built to keep winning, even with the coming salary cap crunch. Of all the heavyweights, the Lightning may be the one with the best shot at closing the gap on the Penguins.
Total playoff years: 20SC, 19, 18CF, 16CF, 15SCF, 14, 11CF, 07, 06
Average: 1.93 points per season
 
  • Like
Reactions: Dennis Bonvie

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad