| Rank | Player | Draft POS | Vote % | 2018 Result | 2017 Result |
| 1 | Jack Hughes | 2019 #1 | 88.6 | Ty Smith | Nico Hischier |
| 2 | Ty Smith | 2018 #17 | 86.4 | Michael McLeod | Michael McLeod |
| 3 | Jesper Boqvist | 2017 #36 | 74.8 | Joey Anderson | Steven Santini |
| 4 | MacKenzie Blackwood | 2015 #42 | 88.6 | Jesper Boqvist | John Quenneville |
| 5 | Joey Anderson | 2016 #73 | 37.0 | John Quenneville | Blake Speers |
| 6 | Aarne Talvitie | 2017 #160 | 35.1 | Reilly Walsh | Yegor Rykov |
| 7 | Reilly Walsh | 2017 #81 | 51.4 | Brett Seney | T-Mackenzie Blackwood |
| 8 | Michael McLeod | 2016 #12 | 50.7 | Jeremy Davies | T-Jesper Boqvist |
| 9 | Nathan Bastian | 2016 #41 | 35.1 | Fabian Zetterlund | Joey Anderson |
| 10 | Daniil Misyul | 2019 #70 | 35.8 | Blake Speers | Miles Wood |
| 11 | Marian Studenic | 2017 #143 | 42.3 | Aarne Talvitie | Mirco Mueller |
| 12 | Brett Seney | 2015 #157 | 32.8 | MacKenzie Blackwood | Nikita Popugayev |
| 13 | Fabian Zetterlund | 2017 #63 | 51.2 | T-Nathan Bastian | Reilly Walsh |
| 14 | Nikita Okhotyuk | 2019 #61 | 33.3 | T-Colby Sissions | Nathan Bastian |
| 15 | Brandon Gignac | 2016 #80 | 33.3 | Marian Studenic | Brandon Gignac |
| 16 | Mikhail Maltsev | 2016 #102 | 34.2 | Matt Hellickson | Fabian Zetterlund |
| 17 | Michael Vukojevic | 2019 #82 | 31.6 | Xavier Bernard | Jesper Bratt |
[/TBODY]
Added: Mitchell Hoelscher
Remaining eligible prospects:
Cole Brady
Evan Cormier
Arseni Gritsyuk
Jeremy Groleau
Nikola Pasic
Yegor Sharangovich
Colby Sissions
Blake Speers
Tyce Thompson
Colton White
Yegor Zaitsev
