Not that I want to participate in this debate or anything but I don't get this point...
How many times did it happen that the 4th overall pick was the 4th best player in the draft? Early picks always get "outplayed" by guys drafted later, except sometimes when a McDavid is 1st OA
St-Louis drafted
Alex Pietrangelo 4th OA in 2008, was it a bad pick? Karlsson, Josi and Carlson, just to name a few, are better, so does it make it a bad pick?
Brady's brother got picked 6th OA in 2016 but might end up the 3rd best player in his draft. He's an absolute beast. I don't see why Brady would be much worse than his dad and brother, it's not a Wayne vs Keith comparison here.