Hoffman is an absolute weapon on the power play and in overtime, but he is not a great 5v5 player. For me, the bigger question is if we trade McCabe, are we just going without any physical, stay at home D this season? I'm interested to see what happens and who they target (if anyone) to play the "shutdown" minutes.
IMO McCabe had an excellent first part of the season but he fell way off after Christmas. Similar to Scandella who was very solid his first year and a tire fire his second year. It's hard to know what you're going to get from these guys.