Lol another broad statement. I'm not even going to explain why I disagree because I made numerous posts in the draft thread talking about it. But I'll put it this way I actually cheered when Montreal picked Caufield, because that meant we wouldn't be able to waste our pick on him.
Time will tell if I'm right ot wrong about Caufield, but I'm not particularly worried about it, fairly confident that it won't haunt us. Not saying he can't turn into a decent player, but I don't see him becoming a Superstar, which is the only way it would "haunt" us. Sorry I just don't see much more than a 2nd line PP specialist.
Plus I see Newhook as a potential future 2C who could produce similarly, points wise to Caufield, but with a more rounded game.
I could be wrong, but I don't see a huge difference from Caufield to Newhook in terms of NHL potential. Different players type of players, overall fairly close in talent.