If all three are healthy there is no question that I'd take Josi+Fiala, but if one of those two cannot I'd take Weber anytime.
Well, that's exactly my point.
I only tried to explain why I think Fiala can boost this team more than Weber.
Look at Meiers immediate impact, and he's not better than Fiala.
Timo is more complete, but less flashy if you want
If Weber replaces Genazzi on a 15min role it's fine to me, but that's not what makes the team win their key games.
I'm not bashing Weber, he's had a tremendous career and not many would've given him that.
But we're in a lucky position now to reject one-dimensional players even if they've written 'NHL' on their equipment.
You could be right that he played beside Streit then, but I doubt that Weber was the #1 of that pair
Another year, he was so shaky that they demoted him to #7 and used him 3mins per game on the PP.