Speculation: 2018-2019 Transaction Discussions & Speculation

My Special Purpose

Registered User
Apr 8, 2008
8,151
21,787
Hey gang. Jerk coming in peace, working on a trade value project. How would you all rank the Stars by trade value (the top 5-8 or so)? Think of it this way, pick two guys and say "if I could only have one of these two guys, who would I take?" Start at the bottom and go up the list like that.

Age, contract and performance all count. No-movement clauses and "untouchability" don't.


I'd probably rank your guys like this, but please let me know where I'm wrong and who I forgot. I'm trying to keep this to NHL players, so avoid guys with fewer than 40 games in the league. Thanks!

John Klingberg, 26, $4.25m, 2022
Miro Heiskanen, 19, $894k, 2021
Jamie Benn, 29, $9.5m, 2025

Tyler Seguin, 27, $9.85m, 2027
Ben Bishop, 32, $4.917m,2023
Esa Lindell, 24, $2.2m, 2019
Alex Radulov, 32, $6.25m, 2022
 

BfantZ

Registered User
Jun 22, 2017
2,635
1,144
Hey gang. Jerk coming in peace, working on a trade value project. How would you all rank the Stars by trade value (the top 5-8 or so)? Think of it this way, pick two guys and say "if I could only have one of these two guys, who would I take?" Start at the bottom and go up the list like that.

Age, contract and performance all count. No-movement clauses and "untouchability" don't.


I'd probably rank your guys like this, but please let me know where I'm wrong and who I forgot. I'm trying to keep this to NHL players, so avoid guys with fewer than 40 games in the league. Thanks!

John Klingberg, 26, $4.25m, 2022
Miro Heiskanen, 19, $894k, 2021
Jamie Benn, 29, $9.5m, 2025

Tyler Seguin, 27, $9.85m, 2027
Ben Bishop, 32, $4.917m,2023
Esa Lindell, 24, $2.2m, 2019
Alex Radulov, 32, $6.25m, 2022
Heiskanen
Seguin
Klingberg
Radulov
Benn
Lindell
Bishop
 

Kcb12345

Registered User
Jun 6, 2017
28,950
22,177
Hey gang. Jerk coming in peace, working on a trade value project. How would you all rank the Stars by trade value (the top 5-8 or so)? Think of it this way, pick two guys and say "if I could only have one of these two guys, who would I take?" Start at the bottom and go up the list like that.

Age, contract and performance all count. No-movement clauses and "untouchability" don't.


I'd probably rank your guys like this, but please let me know where I'm wrong and who I forgot. I'm trying to keep this to NHL players, so avoid guys with fewer than 40 games in the league. Thanks!

John Klingberg, 26, $4.25m, 2022
Miro Heiskanen, 19, $894k, 2021
Jamie Benn, 29, $9.5m, 2025

Tyler Seguin, 27, $9.85m, 2027
Ben Bishop, 32, $4.917m,2023
Esa Lindell, 24, $2.2m, 2019
Alex Radulov, 32, $6.25m, 2022

My list is the same as Bfantz's

Heiskanen
Seguin
Klingberg
Radulov
Benn
Lindell
Bishop
 

Satan

MIGHTY
Apr 13, 2010
91,166
12,767
Lapland
Hey gang. Jerk coming in peace, working on a trade value project. How would you all rank the Stars by trade value (the top 5-8 or so)? Think of it this way, pick two guys and say "if I could only have one of these two guys, who would I take?" Start at the bottom and go up the list like that.

Age, contract and performance all count. No-movement clauses and "untouchability" don't.


I'd probably rank your guys like this, but please let me know where I'm wrong and who I forgot. I'm trying to keep this to NHL players, so avoid guys with fewer than 40 games in the league. Thanks!

John Klingberg, 26, $4.25m, 2022
Miro Heiskanen, 19, $894k, 2021
Jamie Benn, 29, $9.5m, 2025

Tyler Seguin, 27, $9.85m, 2027
Ben Bishop, 32, $4.917m,2023
Esa Lindell, 24, $2.2m, 2019
Alex Radulov, 32, $6.25m, 2022

Klingberg
Heiskanen
Seguin
Benn
Radulov
Lindell
Bishop
 
  • Like
Reactions: My Special Purpose

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

-->