Speculation: 2018-2019 Trade rumors thread Pt 2

[Sojourn]

The scouts thing, to me, is one of those speculations that is brought up so often that the statistical likelihood of it eventually being linked to an actual trade is about 100%. It just happens so often, that eventually it will be right.

But I don’t think it’s especially noteworthy. Blindfold me, and put a dart board in front of me and a shitload of darts. Eventually, I’ll hit a bullseye. But as far as results go, I will be neither accurate or precise.

Edit: Not criticizing others for believing it. I just don’t.

 

[dracom]

Stars fan here.

What would it take to get Silfverberg and Manson or Montour

for both players, it would cost a lot more than the Stars would be willing to move.

 

[WhatTheDuck]

Stars fan here.

What would it take to get Silfverberg and Manson or Montour

Silfverberg could cost a 1st depending on the market. The other two I just can't see moving realistically, opens up a giant hole in the system.

 

[hagan88]

Would you move Manson first?

 

[Dr Johnny Fever]

Would you move Manson first?

Silfverberg is either a deadline deal or he stays. Manson would 99% only be a summer deal if at all.

 

[WhatTheDuck]

Would you move Manson first?

I wouldn't move either unless we are getting another top 4 RHD back. Again, you are asking us to create a giant hole in our top 4. One that could take years to fill given the market for quality RHD.

 

[KaseMeOutside]

^ I'd be surprised if Bob is a fan of Ho Sang, values character so highly.

I think that's relative to the cost in this case

 

[MMC]

 

[MMC]

It's too bad Sustr is hurt. I would've liked to have played him up until the TDL just for the miniscule chance that someone decides to give up 7th or something for him as depth.

 

[duxfan1101]

It's too bad Sustr is hurt. I would've liked to have played him up until the TDL just for the miniscule chance that someone decides to give up 7th or something for him as depth.

He's not hurt, he's a healthy scratch

 

[MMC]

He's not hurt, he's a healthy scratch

My mistake, still, I'd rather we play him and let SD have their captain back.

 

[The Mighty Duck Man]

My mistake, still, I'd rather we play him and let SD have their captain back.

In this evaluation period I'm cool with Megna getting an extended look. Welinski for practices too, I guess. It is weird Sustr isnt playing at all but I wonder if he'll be dealt anyway.

 

[Dr Johnny Fever]

Bob has previously said, guys sometimes get called up as a reward for their hard work and success in SD. Even if the don't play here they get an NHL check. I could see him doing that for guys vs using a roster spot for a guy like Sustr.

 

[Duck Off]

Looking at our roster and if we’re serious about some of these young guys getting roster spots next season; Shore and Silfverberg have to go. I assume Eaves will be bought out?

Which young guys seem nhl destined next year? Terry, Jones, and Comtois? Maybe Steel and Sherwood?

 

[Dr Johnny Fever]

Guys will come to camp and earn their way on to the roster. Many have shown flashes of success this year but that's far from locking up a spot next year. We've seen that movie plenty of times. Then there's always those injury recalls the Ducks are famous for. My guess would be maybe Terry and Jones for opening night. Sherwood could be on the 4th line.

 

[Anaheim4ever]

Looking at our roster and if we’re serious about some of these young guys getting roster spots next season; Shore and Silfverberg have to go. I assume Eaves will be bought out?

Which young guys seem nhl destined next year? Terry, Jones, and Comtois? Maybe Steel and Sherwood?

Jones will at least make it as a PKing LW.

 

[The Mighty Duck Man]

Jones will at least make it as a PKing LW.

Problem is, do you want him to? He's only a first year pro and between suspensions and injuries he hasn't played a ton of games since being drafted. Overcooking him in the AHL isnt the worst option.

 

[Anaheim4ever]

Problem is, do you want him to? He's only a first year pro and between suspensions and injuries he hasn't played a ton of games since being drafted. Overcooking him in the AHL isnt the worst option.

3rd line LW could be a fit for him especially if Shore moves to the 4th line or traded.

 

[Paul4587]

Looking at our roster and if we’re serious about some of these young guys getting roster spots next season; Shore and Silfverberg have to go. I assume Eaves will be bought out?

Which young guys seem nhl destined next year? Terry, Jones, and Comtois? Maybe Steel and Sherwood?

Jones and Terry barring massive regression are locks. Depending on whether Henrique is dealt or not Steel could also be here. I think Comtois was a nice surprise this season but also think the small sample size of production has skewed peoples perception of how NHL ready he is. I don't think he's a lock for next year.

 

[Zegs2sendhelp]

Looking at our roster and if we’re serious about some of these young guys getting roster spots next season; Shore and Silfverberg have to go. I assume Eaves will be bought out?

Which young guys seem nhl destined next year? Terry, Jones, and Comtois? Maybe Steel and Sherwood?

I think terry jones n comtois for sure.

Prob 1 of lundestrom or steel.

Sheerwood is a long shot imo, perr-kase-sprong-terry and rakell-ritchie-comtois-jones, shore.

Thats assuming silf is gone, and eaves is gone

 

[The Midnight Burrito]

I don't think Terry is a lock, I think it'll depend on how he does in camp. He probably needs to show more at this level the rest of this year.

 

[Masch78]

I'd say noone is a lock. You have to outplay other players. It would not hurt Comtois to go to the AHL while being a callup. Steel, we will see. Terry and Jones are on the doorstep of being regulars here. I think Shore is a good piece. As is Silfverberg and I'd not deal one of them just because we have some players pushing. Silfverberg will be determined by his contract situation. This will be interesting 7 days.

 

[alcolol]

I dreamt we acquired Vatrano, who currently plays for Florida, in a trade with Boston.. Do I qualify as an insider yet?

 

[ShadowDuck]

LW:
Rakell
Ritchie
Comtois
Jones
(Shore)
<FA?>

RW:
Perry
Kase
Sprong
Terry
(Eaves)

C:
Getzlaf
Henrique
Kesler
Rowney
<Steel>
<Rookie ‘20>

Unless I’m forgetting someone, that’s what our forward group could look like next year. I’m assuming Silf is traded, and I think Shore should be as well. Eaves should be bought out or dumped in a trade. And Bob will have his annual bargain bin bottom 6’er

 

[KyleJRM]

I would be pretty surprised if Steel was an NHL full-timer next year. He needs to show more as an offense-only C than he has so far in the AHL.

Terry is a lock, Jones has a pretty good chance, and Sherwood will spend the rest of his career doing the AHL/4th line shuffle.