2018-19 Milbury Trophy

[Hasbro]

Who is your pick for worst GM of the year: The Mike Milbury Trophy?

Click to read more...

 

[Prairie Habs]

Can it be awarded posthumously to Chia?

 

[Rabid Ranger]

Rob Blake for retaining Desjardins.

 

[16thOverallSaveUs]

Pail Fenton

Resume:
Granlund for Fiala (I don’t mind this one)
Rask for Nino (I mind this one)
Coyle for Donato (I like this one)

2018 1st round pick: Filip Johanson

 

[BHD]

Paul Fenton and (if still want to include him) Peter Chiarelli.

 

[Golden Puppers]

Here's a shot of Fenton and Chirelli

 

[BlueDream]

Botterill has to at least be mentioned.

 

[KPower]

Chia pet in a landslide.

 

[Snippit]

Fenton lost every single trade
Botts HM

 

[SpinningEdge]

Eugene Melnyk - because he’s basically GM and deserves worst award of everything

 

[Thrasymachus]

Chiarelli for sure. He did get fired, after all.

The Koskinen contract was the final straw

 

[Hasbro]

Can it be awarded posthumously to Chia?

Being fired in season puts you on the shortlist.

 

[Hasbro]

Eugene Melnyk - because he’s basically GM and deserves worst award of everything

Running away with his second consecutive Ballard Trophy.

 

[discobob]

Due to grace period... The Milbury goes to Mike Milbury

 

[ThreeLeftSkates]

Send it to Garth Snow, if anyone can find him.

 

[Wayne Primeau]

Chiarelli, Fenton, and maybe Botterill as a distant third.

None of Chiarelli's moves can be rationally explained in the slightest.

 

[StupidGenius]

Chiarelli, Fenton, and maybe Botterill as a distant third.

None of Chiarelli's moves can be rationally explained in the slightest.

Flipping Wideman and a 3rd for Petrovic at least made a bit of sense. Outside of that, it's a lot of questionable decisions, or overpayments or both.

 

[snipes]

Chiarelli AINEC

 

[Frosty415]

chia because the dumpster fire somehow got worse before he got fired, also the goalie contract (lul)

 

[avsfan09]

Pail Fenton

Resume:
Granlund for Fiala (I don’t mind this one)
Rask for Nino (I mind this one)
Coyle for Donato (I like this one)

2018 1st round pick: Filip Johanson

I can't say I'm not a fan.

 

[Jacob]

Koskinen, Strome, Manning, gotta be Chiarelli.

 

[pbgoalie]

I’d give Bob Murray a vote.
Brought in Carlyle repeat.
Our defense depth has turned into a bit of a question mark, and our gains from that are limited.
Rode Carlyle until we had no playoff chance and we were in a high pick spot.
Then we fire Carlyle and play our way out of a great chance at a high pick.

I like that we played well late season after Carlyle, and don’t like absolute tanking, but we showed we could have really pushed for the playoffs had we gotten rid of Carlyle last season, or after we started looking somdamned pathetic.

GMBM has really done a solid job over the years, and our drafting record could see us retool quickly, but this season was a damned mess from his standpoint imo

 

[16thOverallSaveUs]

I can't say I'm not a fan.

I’m sure you love it lol. Luckily for us, I’m not sure Sakic is much better

 

[M88K]

Jim Nill.

Played Russian roulette with the season, and continued to downgrade the roster with each move he made, until finally getting something kind of right with Zuccarello.
Wasted cap space on Cogliano, Oleksiak, Lovejoy and failed to address dire needs at scoring. if not for Amazing goaltending, we're talking a lotto team because of his ineptitude

Not to mention the whole "horseshit" situation is squarely on him for putting together a very mediocre roster and expecting everyone to chip in 5-10 more goals

 

[deckercky]

I’m sure you love it lol. Luckily for us, I’m not sure Sakic is much better

Sakic's reputation as a GM will be protected for a long time based on the Duchene trade alone regardless of anything else he does.