Draft position aside...can it be argued that Puljujarvi is much more enticing player at 17/18 year-old player than Hall was at the same age?
We can't compare FNL/Jr stats given these guys were in completely different leagues (playing against men vs boys).
But let's look where we can compare them - the WJHC.
Hall put up 12 points in 6gp in what was a pretty dominant draft-year performance.
JP put up 17points in 7gp in dominating the tournament to the point of being named Tournament MVP.
Then there's the stuff you can't quantify statistically - the "eye test".
The only 3 advantages I see from Hall at 18 compared to JP are:
1) Speed (JP is no slouch, but Hall was a bullet)
2) Grit/Nose-down hockey (Hall crashes the net, goes to the dirty areas to score goals, JP doesn't do this as much, even with his size)
3) Familiarity with the North American game (bigger factor than we make out)
Literally EVERY other category I see JP dominating
1) Size. Nuff said
2) Shot (not even close tbh. You have a near-elite sniper in JP who can shoot from anywhere with deceptiveness, velocity, and accuracy versus the average-at-best shooter in Hall)
3) Passing (although he's improved significantly since his rookie year, Hall at 18 is nowhere near what JP is)
4) Hockey IQ (JP has arguably more at 18 than Hall does now)
5) 2-way game
6) Stickhandling
I see a much better player coming from the draft in JP than I did with Hall.
With even secondary offensive opportunities (no McDavid at ES) - I can see this guy putting up 50 points with relative ease as soon as next year.
I feel like the eye-test is a better judge when watching things like WJC, too many variables for stats, whereas it's nice to see how a players skillset matches up against the other top players in a top competition.
Random comments on your assessment:
Skating - too hard for me to form an opinion on this, they're both dynamic skaters and I can't tell who's quicker with what's available to compare. I'm fine with giving it to Hall but it's close either way and hard to say it's a distinct advantage.
The NA factor is an important one - but Jesse does a play a style well suited to NA rinks at least.
Shot - many clips I've seen of Pulju actually reminded me so much of Hall. Flubbing the puck, not getting any lift on it..just a lack of consistent snipe action. But I've also seen his shot when on and it's definitely better than Hall. Anyway there is a lot of room for improvement here from Jesse IMO.
Stickhandling - Jesse mishandles the puck a lot, or at least this year he did and I've seen it a common complaint. Reminds me of Hall for that too
.
It is hard to give Hall the edge in anything though really, JP is a pretty damn complete prospect. A big part of Hall's package is his motor - uncommon to find relentless players like that - and JP even matches him in that. He's got way better size and still matches him in skating. And then he's got the higher end IQ to put it all together. Prospect wise he's kind of just a bigger and smarter Hall.
Super excited to see him play.