Man, Grabo is good with the Capitals. The Capitals however, kind of suck. They don't play as physical as the Leafs, and Oates doesn't require the defensive commitment out of his players, not like Carlyle does anyways. (And yeah I realize we've been pretty bad defensively, point still stands.)
What I'm trying to say is Grabovski was just not going to work out here. Carlyle clearly didn't like his game, and as good as Grabo is doing in Washington, I highly doubt he would have that production right now if he were playing for the Leafs, simply because he no longer fit into the system, and wasn't going to be given the minutes he needs to succeed under Carlyle. That much is pretty clear.
He probably would've been struggling to score, just like last season, and the same fans who miss him would probably be calling to trade him.