db23
Guest
1 Fleury - First round goalies are a dicey proposition, but Fleury was at least adequate in his NHL time and was very sharp in junior. Still playing in the playoffs.
B
2 Stall - Did nothing to hurt his high evaluation in his first NHL season. Solid debut.
B
3 Horton - Showed perhaps the most reason for optimism among the top picks. Is half a year younger than most of the others and will be a dynamic player.
B+
4 Zherdev - Arrived in NHL sooner than expected and showed the top drawer talent advertised.
B
5 Vanek - On cruise control in the NCAA. He dominates the competition there and would benefit from a step up.
C+
6 Michalek - Won a spot on the team then was injured for most of the year. Showed he will be a solid two way guy.
C+
7 Suter - Wasn't really the dominating player he was expected to be as an NCAA freshman. It does not appear that he will be a top end offensive defenseman, and at 6-1, 190 pounds he can't be a major physical presence either.
C
8 Coburn - Seems to have plateaued in his performance the past three years in the WHL. Not a great sign.
C
9 Phaneuf - Showed more upside and intensity than the other defenders drafted ahead of him.
B
10 Kastitsyn - Didn't appear to be a happy camper in Russia, and just went through the motions at the WJC. The concerns about his head remain, but now they are less about epileptic seizures and more about maturity and work ethic.
C-
B
2 Stall - Did nothing to hurt his high evaluation in his first NHL season. Solid debut.
B
3 Horton - Showed perhaps the most reason for optimism among the top picks. Is half a year younger than most of the others and will be a dynamic player.
B+
4 Zherdev - Arrived in NHL sooner than expected and showed the top drawer talent advertised.
B
5 Vanek - On cruise control in the NCAA. He dominates the competition there and would benefit from a step up.
C+
6 Michalek - Won a spot on the team then was injured for most of the year. Showed he will be a solid two way guy.
C+
7 Suter - Wasn't really the dominating player he was expected to be as an NCAA freshman. It does not appear that he will be a top end offensive defenseman, and at 6-1, 190 pounds he can't be a major physical presence either.
C
8 Coburn - Seems to have plateaued in his performance the past three years in the WHL. Not a great sign.
C
9 Phaneuf - Showed more upside and intensity than the other defenders drafted ahead of him.
B
10 Kastitsyn - Didn't appear to be a happy camper in Russia, and just went through the motions at the WJC. The concerns about his head remain, but now they are less about epileptic seizures and more about maturity and work ethic.
C-