2003-2008 top 10 NHL draft

noBSleafsFAN

Registered User
Jun 13, 2010
642
0
Toronto
1. (2005 1st overall): Sidney Crosby
2. (2004 1st overall): Alex Ovechkin
3. (2008 1st overall): Steven Stamkos
4. (2004 2nd overall): Evgeni Malkin
5. (2003 2nd overal): Eric Staal
6. (2006 4th overall) Nicklas Backstrom
7. (2003 19th overall): Ryan Getzlaf
8. (2006 3rd overall): Jonathan Toews
9. (2007 1st overall): Patrick Kane
10. (2004 29th overall): Mike Green

Notables:
(2003 9th overall): Dion Phaneuf
(2003 23rd overall): Ryan Kesler
(2003 24th overall): Mike Richards
(2003 28th overall): Corey Perry
(2003 49th overall): Shea Weber
(2005 2nd overall): Bobby Ryan
(2005 5th overall): Carey Price
(2006 5th overall): Phil Kessel
(2008 2nd overall): Drew Doughty
 
Last edited:

Csonked Out

Registered User
Mar 20, 2007
3,513
1,091
Bismarck, ND
1. (2005 1st overall): Sidney Crosby
2. (2004 1st overall): Alex Ovechkin
3. (2008 1st overall): Steven Stamkos
4. (2004 2nd overall): Evgeni Malkin
5. (2003 1st overal): Eric Staal
6. (2006 4th overall) Nicklas Backstrom
7. (2003 19th overall): Ryan Getzlaf
8. (2006 3rd overall): Jonathan Toews
9. (2007 1st overall): Patrick Kane
10. (2004 29th overall): Mike Green

Notables:
(2003 9th overall): Dion Phaneuf
(2003 23rd overall): Ryan Kesler
(2003 24th overall): Mike Richards
(2003 28th overall): Corey Perry
(2003 49th overall): Shea Weber
(2005 2nd overall): Bobby Ryan
(2005 5th overall): Carey Price
(2006 5th overall): Phil Kessel
(2008 2nd overall): Drew Doughty

I would probably remove either Bobby Ryan or Dion and add in Parise.
 

R S

Registered User
Sep 18, 2006
25,468
10
no Brent Burns? really or Parise

:help:


Doughty should be in top 10 easily....

Just looking at your list I would do...

1. (2005 1st overall): Sidney Crosby
2. (2004 1st overall): Alex Ovechkin
3. (2008 1st overall): Steven Stamkos
4. (2004 2nd overall): Evgeni Malkin
5. (2006 4th overall) Nicklas Backstrom
6. (2008 2nd overall): Drew Doughty
7. (2003 1st overal): Eric Staal
8. (2003 19th overall): Ryan Getzlaf
9. (2006 3rd overall): Jonathan Toews
10. (2005 5th overall): Carey Price



Notables:
(2003 23rd overall): Ryan Kesler
(2007 1st overall): Patrick Kane
(2004 29th overall): Mike Green
(2003 49th overall): Shea Weber
(2005 2nd overall): Bobby Ryan
(2003 24th overall): Mike Richards
(2003 28th overall): Corey Perry
 

SeanVT395

It's Not Even Close
May 15, 2010
3,145
20
Vermont
Eric Staal was drafted 2nd overall, not 1st.

Also I would drop Toews and Green out of the top 10 and put in Doughty and Parise.
 
Last edited:

Ryan English

@ryanenglish_FC
Nov 14, 2010
378
1
Halifax, NS
:help:


Doughty should be in top 10 easily....

Just looking at your list I would do...

1. (2005 1st overall): Sidney Crosby
2. (2004 1st overall): Alex Ovechkin
3. (2008 1st overall): Steven Stamkos
4. (2004 2nd overall): Evgeni Malkin
5. (2006 4th overall) Nicklas Backstrom
6. (2008 2nd overall): Drew Doughty
7. (2003 1st overal): Eric Staal
8. (2003 19th overall): Ryan Getzlaf
9. (2006 3rd overall): Jonathan Toews
10. (2005 5th overall): Carey Price

I would take any of the notables over price. though he has been playing better goalies just arent that valuable.


Notables:
(2003 23rd overall): Ryan Kesler
(2007 1st overall): Patrick Kane
(2004 29th overall): Mike Green
(2003 49th overall): Shea Weber
(2005 2nd overall): Bobby Ryan
(2003 24th overall): Mike Richards
(2003 28th overall): Corey Perry

I would take any of the notables over price. though he has been playing better goalies just arent that valuable.

Crosby - 05
Ovechkin - 04
Stammer - 08
Malkin - 04
Staal - 03
Toews - 06
Getzlaf - 03
Doughty - 08
Parise - 05
Richards - 03

Notables in order
Backstrom
Weber
Green
Ryan
Kane
Kesler
Perry
Price
 
Last edited:

dmacin2*

Guest
Doughty and Weber are miles ahead of Mike Green. Where is Suter?

Phaneuf and Kessel should be nowhere near this list.
 

8BostonRocker24

Registered User
Feb 8, 2006
9,275
8
Silicon Valley
1. (2005 1st overall): Sidney Crosby
2. (2004 1st overall): Alex Ovechkin
3. (2008 1st overall): Steven Stamkos
4. (2004 2nd overall): Evgeni Malkin
5. (2003 2nd overal): Eric Staal
6. (2006 4th overall) Nicklas Backstrom
7. (2003 19th overall): Ryan Getzlaf
8. (2006 3rd overall): Jonathan Toews
9. (2007 1st overall): Patrick Kane
10. (2004 29th overall): Mike Green

Notables:
(2003 9th overall): Dion Phaneuf
(2003 23rd overall): Ryan Kesler
(2003 24th overall): Mike Richards
(2003 28th overall): Corey Perry
(2003 49th overall): Shea Weber
(2005 2nd overall): Bobby Ryan
(2005 5th overall): Carey Price
(2006 5th overall): Phil Kessel
(2008 2nd overall): Drew Doughty
No mention of Ryan Suter, Brent Seabrook, Brent Burns, Marc Staal, Erik Karlsson, or Keith Yandle even though they are considerable better then Neon Dion.

No mention of Zach Parise, Jeff Carter, Loui Eriksson, Anze Kopitar, or Matt Duchene even though they are considerable better then Kessel.
 

forthewild

Registered User
Aug 17, 2009
4,115
0
:help:


Doughty should be in top 10 easily....

Just looking at your list I would do...

1. (2005 1st overall): Sidney Crosby
2. (2004 1st overall): Alex Ovechkin
3. (2008 1st overall): Steven Stamkos
4. (2004 2nd overall): Evgeni Malkin
5. (2006 4th overall) Nicklas Backstrom
6. (2008 2nd overall): Drew Doughty
7. (2003 1st overal): Eric Staal
8. (2003 19th overall): Ryan Getzlaf
9. (2006 3rd overall): Jonathan Toews
10. (2005 5th overall): Carey Price



Notables:
(2003 23rd overall): Ryan Kesler
(2007 1st overall): Patrick Kane
(2004 29th overall): Mike Green
(2003 49th overall): Shea Weber
(2005 2nd overall): Bobby Ryan
(2003 24th overall): Mike Richards
(2003 28th overall): Corey Perry

What exactly do you have against Brent Burns? 2 years ago some dumb GM switched him for D to F because he was incapable of signing forwards which led to him being hurt missing a year with concussion then last year he had sinus infection which prevented him from training much. this year he's dominating forwards, he's scoring goals and playing an all around game, on your top 10 every GM would take Burns 100/100 over Cary Price, you can patchwork a goalie but 6'5'' mobile dman with offensive skills and all around great game don't grow on trees
 

Devilsfan92

Registered User
Jan 4, 2008
14,170
108
Lacks
8470610.jpg
 

pouskin74*

Guest
1. (2005 1st overall): Sidney Crosby
2. (2004 1st overall): Alex Ovechkin
3. (2008 1st overall): Steven Stamkos
4. (2004 2nd overall): Evgeni Malkin
5. (2003 2nd overal): Eric Staal
6. (2006 4th overall) Nicklas Backstrom
7. (2003 19th overall): Ryan Getzlaf
8. (2006 3rd overall): Jonathan Toews
9. (2007 1st overall): Patrick Kane
10. (2004 29th overall): Mike Green

Notables:
(2003 9th overall): Dion Phaneuf
(2003 23rd overall): Ryan Kesler
(2003 24th overall): Mike Richards
(2003 28th overall): Corey Perry
(2003 49th overall): Shea Weber
(2005 2nd overall): Bobby Ryan
(2005 5th overall): Carey Price
(2006 5th overall): Phil Kessel
(2008 2nd overall): Drew Doughty

Stamkos ahead of Malkin? no way!
 

Zubrus Coffee Maker

Blinded by my Zubrus
Nov 14, 2008
5,685
569
Cobourg, ON
I would take any of the notables over price. though he has been playing better goalies just arent that valuable.

Crosby - 05
Ovechkin - 04
Stammer - 08
Malkin - 04
Staal - 03
Toews - 06
Getzlaf - 03
Doughty - 08
Parise - 05
Richards - 03

Notables in order
Backstrom
Weber
Green
Ryan
Kane
Kesler
Perry
Price

parise was drafted in 03 i believe
 

Ron Barr

Doing it to Death
Dec 23, 2009
5,820
0
bdddddddet
Here is my draft order:

1. Sidney Crosby
2. Steven Stamkos
3. Alexander Ovechkin
4. Evgeni Malkin
5. Drew Doughty
6. Ryan Getzlaf
7. Zach Parise
8. Nicklas Backstrom
9. Jonathan Toews
10. Carey Price
11. Shea Weber
12. Mike Richards
13. Patrick Kane

EDIT: Derr derr, 2003-2008.
 
Last edited:

JSilvius*

Guest
No mention of Ryan Suter, Brent Seabrook, Brent Burns, Marc Staal, Erik Karlsson, or Keith Yandle even though they are considerable better then Neon Dion.

No mention of Zach Parise, Jeff Carter, Loui Eriksson, Anze Kopitar, or Matt Duchene even though they are considerable better then Kessel.

The thread title says 2003-2008.
 

YNWA14

Onbreekbaar
Dec 29, 2010
34,543
2,560
1. Crosby
2. Stamkos
3. Malkin
4. Ovechkin (I guess)
5. Parise
6. Getzlaf
7. Richards
8. Toews
9. Doughty
10. Staal
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

-->