You're toughs please...

[CaptainSak]

(First, excuse my english)

It's for a simulated league. Our draft is live and I have the 27th and 30th picks. Which would you prefer to have on your team?

Braydon Coburn OR Shae Weber?

Josh Harding OR David Leneveu?

Eric Fehr OR Patrick Eaves?

Mark Stuart OR Matt Carle?

Mikko Koivu OR Anthony Stewart?

On these 10 prospects, who do yo think will have the most impact in the NHL?

Thanks!

Click to read more...

 

[pooler99]

(First, excuse my english)

It's for a simulated league. Our draft is live and I have the 27th and 30th picks. Which would you prefer to have on your team?

Braydon Coburn OR Shae Weber?

Josh Harding OR David Leneveu?

Eric Fehr OR Patrick Eaves?

Mark Stuart OR Matt Carle?

Mikko Koivu OR Anthony Stewart?

On these 10 prospects, who do yo think will have the most impact in the NHL?

Thanks!

First of all it depends if it's for points only or overall talent (i'll assume it's pts only)

Braydon Coburn OR Shae Weber? easy one

Josh Harding OR David Leneveu? tough call not by much

Eric Fehr OR Patrick Eaves? really tough call moreso if Fehr play's with Alex

Mark Stuart OR Matt Carle? easy one

Mikko Koivu OR Anthony Stewart? pretty even

 

[Prospector]

Braydon Coburn OR Shea Weber? Weber has more potential, especially on offense!

Josh Harding OR David Leneveu? Expect Harding to play a lot next year for the Wilds. He might even take Fernandez's spot

Eric Fehr OR Patrick Eaves? This one is difficult since Fehr did not play yet in the NHL... Eaves is a sure bet

Mark Stuart OR Matt Carle? Carle has huge offensive upsides although Stuart will be a solid physical presence

Mikko Koivu OR Anthony Stewart? Koivu looks like a more defensive third liner, while Anthony Stewart might become a power forward

 

[Buffalo87]

Braydon Coburn OR Shae Weber? Easily

Josh Harding OR David Leneveu?

Eric Fehr OR Patrick Eaves? Very close

Mark Stuart OR Matt Carle?

Mikko Koivu OR Anthony Stewart? I'm not sure if Koivu will ever work out

 

[Blind Gardien]

First of all it depends if it's for points only or overall talent (i'll assume it's pts only)

Braydon Coburn OR Shae Weber? easy one

Josh Harding OR David Leneveu? tough call not by much

Eric Fehr OR Patrick Eaves? really tough call moreso if Fehr play's with Alex

Mark Stuart OR Matt Carle? easy one

Mikko Koivu OR Anthony Stewart? pretty even

Concur. With Carle or Weber being the absolute best of the bunch (excluding goalies).