Your Top 50 List?

Status
Not open for further replies.

kruezer

Registered User
Apr 21, 2002
6,718
274
North Bay
Captain Conservative said:
Radulov-~62
Shishkanov-~45
Weber-~65
Klein-~60
Upshall-~30

Thats where i'd put em I think. I love the preds prospects. What a great young team.
I agree, Shishkanov is the most underrated prospect in the league.
 

Clutch Mediocrity

Registered User
May 8, 2004
1,993
0
Ottawa, Ontario
www.4thegame.com
1. Alexander Ovechkin - Washington
2. Kari Lehtonen - Atlanta
3. Nikolai Zherdev - Columbus
4. Evgeny Malkin - Pittsburgh
5. Dion Phaneuf - Calgary
6. Marc-Andre Fleury - Pittsburgh
7. Ryan Suter - Nashville
8. Nathan Horton - Florida
9. Cam Barker - Chicago (really high on this kid)
10. Zach Parise - New Jersey
11. Alexander Semin - Washington
12. Hannu Toivonen - Boston
13. Jeff Carter - Philadelphia
14. Fedor Tjutin - NY Rangers
15. Milan Michalek - San Jose
16. Maxime Ouellet - Washington
17. Dustin Brown - Los Angeles
18. Lauri Tukonen - Los Angeles
19. Ryan Getzlaf - Anaheim
20. Niklas Kronwall - Detroit
21. Ryan Miller - Buffalo
22. Steve Eminger - Washington
23. Denis Grebeshkov - Los Angeles
24. Patrick O'Sullivan - Minnesota
25. Ilja Bryzgalov - Anaheim
26. Ray Emery - Ottawa (I'm high on the guy. But even as a Sens fan, I can't see him in the top 20)
27. Alexander Steen - Toronto
28. Robbie Schremp - Edmonton
29. Thomas Vanek - Buffalo
30. Carlo Coliacovo - Toronto
31. Marek Schwarz - St. Louis (not at all impressed at his play with the Giants....)
32. Igor Grigorenk - Detroit
33. Antoine Vermette - Ottawa
34. Anthony Stewart - Florida
35. Alvaro Montoya - NY Rangers
36. Rostislav Olesz - Florida
37. Henrik Lundqvist - NY Rangers
38. Christopher Higgins - Montreal
39. Mike Richards - Philadelphia
40. Braydon Coburn - Atlanta
41. Andrei Kostitsyn - Montreal
42. Loui Eriksson - Dallas
43. Anton Babchuk - Chicag
44. Ladislav Smid - Anaheim
45. Jeff Tambellini - Los Angeles
46. Antero Niittymaki - Philadelphia
47. Ryan Whitney - Pittsburgh
48. Derek Roy- Buffalo
49. Eric Fehr - Washington
50. Andreij Meszaros - Ottawa (maybe I'm a homer but I love this kid's game. Great start to the season in the WHL has him rounding out my list).

There's my list. Probably a bit bias and all but I'm alright with my top 50.
 

MrMastodonFarm*

Registered User
Jul 5, 2004
6,207
0
Enoch said:
Alexander Radulov
Timofei Shishkanov
Shea Weber
Keven Klein
Scottie Upshall
Weber is underrated by the leauge, but overrated by Nashville Fans. I would have him in the fringe top 50. Upshall would be higher if he wasn't so damn injured all the time.
 

big_steve

Registered User
Dec 6, 2003
871
0
Newfoundland
1. Alexander Ovechkin- Washington
2. Kari Lehtonen- Atlanta
3. Yevgeny Malkin- Pittsburgh
4. Nikolai Zherdev- Columbus
5. Dion Phaneuf- Calgary
6. Marc-Andre Fleury- Pittsburgh
7. Ryan Suter- Nashville
8. Nathan Horton- Florida
9. Milan Michalek- San Jose
10. Zach Parise- New Jersey
11. Jeff Carter- Philadelphia
12. Alexander Semin- Washington
13. Dustin Brown- Los Angeles
14. Cam Barker- Chicago
15. Hannu Toivonen- Boston
16. Maxime Ouellet- Washington
17. Fedor Tjutin- New York Rangers
18. Ray Emery- Ottawa
19. Denis Grebeshkov- Los Angeles
20. Niklas Kronwell- Detroit
21. Lauri Tukonen- Los Angeles
22. Thomas Vanek- Buffalo
23. Ryan Getzlaf- Anaheim
24. Ryan Miller- Buffalo
25. Marek Schwarz- St. Louis
26. Steve Eminger- Washington
27. Patrick O'Sullivan- Minnesota
28. Alexander Steen- Toronto
29. Robbie Schremp- Edmonton
30. Ilya(or is it Ilyja) Bryzgalov- Anaheim
31. Carlo Colaiacovo- Toronto
32. Henrik Lundqvist- New York Rangers
33. Braydon Coburn- Atlanta
34. Alvaro Montoya- New York Rangers
35. Andrei Kostitsyn- Montreal
36. Rostislav Olesz- Florida
37. Anton Babchuk- Chicago
38. Anthony Stewart- Florida
39. Mike Richards- Philadelphia
40. Loui Eriksson- Dallas
41. Igor Grigorenko- Detroit
42. Antero Niittymaki- Philadelphia
43. Christopher Higgins- Montreal
44. Jozef Balej- New York Rangers
45. Jeff Tambellini- Los Angeles
46. Ryan Whitney- Pittsburgh
47. Mark Stuart- Boston(a homer pick there maybe but I feel he's probably good enough and he seems like he's a safe pick so...)
48. Lukas Krajicek- Florida
49. Ladislav Smid- Anaheim
50. Eric Fehr- Washington
 

Chaos

And the winner is...
Sep 2, 2003
7,968
18
TX
1. Alexander Ovechkin
2. Kari Lehtonen
3. Evgeni Malkin
4. Nikolai Zherdev
5. Dion Phaneuf
6. Ryan Suter
7. Milan Michalek
8. Marc-Andre Fleury
9. Nathan Horton
10. Jeff Carter
11. Alexander Semin
12. Zach Parise
13. Dustin Brown
14. Hannu Toivonen
15. Cam Barker
16. Denis Grebeshkov
17. Fedor Tyutin
18. Lauri Tukonen
19. Ryan Getzlaf
20. Maxime Ouellet
21. Nicklas Kronwall
22. Thomas Vanek
23. Patrick O'Sullivan
24. Steve Eminger
25. Ilya Bryzgolov
26. Alexander Steen
27. Henrik Lundqvist
28. Anton Babchuk
29. Carlo Colaiacovo
30. Al Montoya
31. Loui Eriksson
32. Rostislav Olesz
33. Ryan Whitney
34. Anthony Stewart
35. Braydon Coburn
36. Marek Schwarz
37. Chris Higgins
38. Andrei Kostitsyn
39. Andrew Ladd
40. Mike Richards
41. Ladislav Smid
42. Ray Emery
43. Josef Balej
44. Jeff Tambellini
45. Antero Niittymaki
46. Eric Fehr
47. Alexander Radulov
48. Mark Stuart
49. Igor Grigorenko
50. Jussi Jokinen- Everyone else is homering it up here, so I figured I'd add the guy who just led the Karlaja Cup in goals ;)
 
Jul 29, 2003
31,639
5,336
Saskatoon
Visit site
Chaos said:
1. Alexander Ovechkin
2. Kari Lehtonen
3. Evgeni Malkin
4. Nikolai Zherdev
5. Dion Phaneuf
6. Ryan Suter
7. Milan Michalek
8. Marc-Andre Fleury
9. Nathan Horton
10. Jeff Carter
11. Alexander Semin
12. Zach Parise
13. Dustin Brown
14. Hannu Toivonen
15. Cam Barker
16. Denis Grebeshkov
17. Fedor Tyutin
18. Lauri Tukonen
19. Ryan Getzlaf
20. Maxime Ouellet
21. Nicklas Kronwall
22. Thomas Vanek
23. Patrick O'Sullivan
24. Steve Eminger
25. Ilya Bryzgolov
26. Alexander Steen
27. Henrik Lundqvist
28. Anton Babchuk
29. Carlo Colaiacovo
30. Al Montoya
31. Loui Eriksson
32. Rostislav Olesz
33. Ryan Whitney
34. Anthony Stewart
35. Braydon Coburn
36. Marek Schwarz
37. Chris Higgins
38. Andrei Kostitsyn
39. Andrew Ladd
40. Mike Richards
41. Ladislav Smid
42. Ray Emery
43. Josef Balej
44. Jeff Tambellini
45. Antero Niittymaki
46. Eric Fehr
47. Alexander Radulov
48. Mark Stuart
49. Igor Grigorenko
50. Jussi Jokinen- Everyone else is homering it up here, so I figured I'd add the guy who just led the Karlaja Cup in goals ;)

My exact list, but take Jokinen out and put Perry in someone. I know you're all thinking "there's his homer pick", and well, you're partially right, but when a guy is doing this well and is getting better as time goes by, I'd say he's a top 50 prospect.
 

Enoch

This is my boomstick
Jul 2, 2003
14,239
872
Cookeville TN
MrMastodonFarm said:
Weber is underrated by the leauge, but overrated by Nashville Fans. I would have him in the fringe top 50. Upshall would be higher if he wasn't so damn injured all the time.

Your probably right about us overrating him, but its probably due to the lack of a bruising defensemen with good size. Suter, Hammer, and Klein all have great hitting skills, but Weber has more of the physique to do it with.

Completely agree about Upshall. I wasn't surprised to see him fall after his injuries last season....although it is curious to see others with such huge injuries still very prominent on the list. Either way, hopefully he will have a good year in Milwuakee.
 

Chaos

And the winner is...
Sep 2, 2003
7,968
18
TX
Hercules Rockefeller said:
My exact list, but take Jokinen out and put Perry in someone. I know you're all thinking "there's his homer pick", and well, you're partially right, but when a guy is doing this well and is getting better as time goes by, I'd say he's a top 50 prospect.

Ah I knew I was forgetting someone...I'd probably put Perry in place of Grigorenko and drop Igor off the list..Jokinen stays at the very end ;)
 

KingPurpleDinosaur

Bandwagon Kings Fan
Dec 17, 2002
2,897
0
irvine, ca
www.anteaterhockey.com
man, i have to admit i would agree with your list a lot mroe then the HF list. job very well done. i think people put too much weight into "potential" and not enough weight into the probable level they will end up. in the end, it doens't matter if you have all the tools in the world, if you can't tap into your potential and end up a 3rd liner, you are STILL a 3rd liner. from the way people make it sound, they would rather take a 3rd liner with a mountain full of potential then a 2nd liner who is doing the best he can do.
 

PanthersRule96

Registered User
Jun 15, 2003
6,048
0
Visit site
Lukas Krajicek should be on every list. There was no argument over him like there was for Kesler, but he has more offensive ability as a forward than Kesler does ( :eek: ) ...zing.. Vancouver fans.

Kesler's a decent prospect but Krajicek is easily top 40.

BTW, Shishkanov should be like #20 on these lists. One scout said the only difference between him and Kovalchuk is the desire to score goals. Everything else is there.

Stewart is low on a lot of lists here. BUt his offensive upside remains a question so I think that's fair.

From FLA, on every list, these players HAVE to be inclued,
Horton
Stewart
Olesz
Krajicek

Players top 50-75,
Rob Globke
David Shantz
Filip Novak
Kamil Kreps

players in top 120:
Taticek
Roussin
Stefan Meyer
Greg Campbell
 

hockeyfan125

Registered User
Jul 10, 2004
20,017
0
MrMastodonFarm said:
Because the guy with the name PanthersRule says so.
I really don't understand why you go around dissing other fans, when you yourself are one of the bigger homers on here.
 

MrMastodonFarm*

Registered User
Jul 5, 2004
6,207
0
jtuzzi21 said:
I really don't understand why you go around dissing other fans, when you yourself are one of the bigger homers on here.
Can you find another reason why Krajicek MUST be in the top 50 besides a Panthers fan saying so?
 

Vlad The Impaler

Registered User
Feb 27, 2002
12,315
644
Montreal
PanthersRule said:
BTW, Shishkanov should be like #20 on these lists. One scout said the only difference between him and Kovalchuk is the desire to score goals. Everything else is there.

That scout is on drugs.
 

hockeyfan125

Registered User
Jul 10, 2004
20,017
0
MrMastodonFarm said:
Can you find another reason why Krajicek MUST be in the top 50 besides a Panthers fan saying so?
I'm not basing my comment at that, I don't think Kraijecek should be on... but its not a stretch to say he should. Even if he is a Florida fan, he does have an opinion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

-->