Young D-Men #5

[CuSa_1]

The point of this poll is if you were drafting from the listed guys who would you select? Take into count production, potential, whatever you want (Dmen under 25)....

1. Bouwmeester
2. Pitkanen
3. Hamhuis
4. (Brad) Stuart

Click to read more...

 

[Captain Conservative]

The point of this poll is if you were drafting from the listed guys who would you select? Take into count production, potential, whatever you want (Dmen under 25)....

1. Bouwmeester
2. Pitkanen
3. Hamhuis
4. (Brad) Stuart

Phaneuf

Add Eminger/Morrisonn

 

[CuSa_1]

Phaneuf

Add Eminger/Morrisonn

Do you have a preference on which one gets added 1st?

 

[Jeffrey]

add eminger

 

[kovalchuk17atl]

Add Coburn. Second choice for adding is Eminger.

I picked Phaneuf...

 

[Captain Conservative]

I prefer Eminger, I think his potential is much greater than Morrisonns

 

[Enoch]

Phaneuf should not be on this list. If he is, then you need to add other defensive prospects like Suter, Coburn, etc.

 

[CuSa_1]

Phaneuf should not be on this list. If he is, then you need to add other defensive prospects like Suter, Coburn, etc.

Phaneuf was voted to be added to the list.

 

[mikerr]

Voted Jackman - Add Kalinin - won't be 24 until July already on the Sabres top pairing.

 

[Special Ed]

Orpik (although Phaneuf definetly has the best potential of anyone on the list probably)

Add: Ryan Whitney, he's been tearing it up in the AHL playoffs finally showing glimpses of why he was selected 5th overall in 2002

 

[eSabre]

The fact that Dmitri Kalinin isn't even an option at this point is pathetic.

 

[BrettNYR]

Orpik (although Phaneuf definetly has the best potential of anyone on the list probably)

Add: Ryan Whitney, he's been tearing it up in the AHL playoffs finally showing glimpses of why he was selected 5th overall in 2002

If we added everyone that everyone says should be added, we would have about 30 players on this poll.

 

[Classic Devil]

Other: Dimitri Kalinin

 

[littleHossa]

Phaneuf, Add Kalinin.

 

[Jacob]

I'd add Kalinin and Whitney way, way before I'd think about adding Eminger and Morrisson.

 

[canucksfan]

Jackman

 

[Ajacied]

Klesla..

Add Kalinin..

 

[dumpnchase]

Picked Phaneuf.

Scott Hannan should be on this list, just ask Weight/Takchuk/Forsberg.

 

[dumpnchase]

Picked Phaneuf.

Scott Hannan should be on this list, just ask Weight/Takchuk/Forsberg.

Nevermind about Hannan he is 25 not under 25.

 

[Lisa Needs Braces]

Phaneuf, I think he's really gonna be something in the NHL in the future

 

[triggrman]

add Suter

 

[DownFromNJ]

Add: Paul Martin. Was NJ's #2 D-man for awhile.

 

[Captain Conservative]

I'd add Kalinin and Whitney way, way before I'd think about adding Eminger and Morrisson.

Whitney before Eminger and Morissonn? Maybe. Way way before Eminger and Morrisonn? Thats ludicrous. Since i'm in a decidely non-homer mood, i'd say Whitney and Eminger deserve to be on this poll equally. Morrisonn probably doesnt belong on the list really. His offensive upside is 20-25 pts, and as a #3 dman, if everything falls just right in his development. I'd say that Whitney and Eminger could both turn into great #1 dman if they fufill their potential.

 

[Senor Rational]

Robyn Rheger....isnt he just 25 years old? Correct me if Im wrong

-Senor Rational