Dave is a killer
Dave's a Mess
http://www.cbc.ca/story/sports/national/2006/09/22/hockey-decision.html
Mods please move this to correct thread or delete if already posted
Mods please move this to correct thread or delete if already posted
Does that mean that the boys who can't make the boy's team can try-out for the girls team.
I think it's a mistake and continous the precived notion that if a girl wants to lay competitive hockey she has to play with boys. As such it will hinder the evolution of girls hockey IMHO.
The Pasternak sisters, who have played hockey since childhood and have been on boys' junior hockey teams outside school, had described the high school girls' team as "a joke."
At that age they shouldn't be playing with the boys team.
Why not... the girl I mentioned in my previous post could easily have played on our boys team had she been allowed. She played with boys her age in organized hockey outside the school just fine.
A room full of 17 year old boys and two girls is a recipe for disaster.
Quote:
The Pasternak sisters, who have played hockey since childhood and have been on boys' junior hockey teams outside school, had described the high school girls' team as "a joke."
If I were a member of the girls' team I would sue the two sisters for:
damage to their dignity and self respect
And why is that?
LOL do you want it spelled out for you??
If you had a 16 year old daughter would u want her showering/changing with 20 other guys?
LOL do you want it spelled out for you??
If you had a 16 year old daughter would u want her showering/changing with 20 other guys?
Just imagine the lawsuits sprawling out of that one
True...if they were willing to sue for "emotional reasons"
Although i dont think theyd actually be showering with the guys, but they would miss out on a few of the pre-game things that the coaches would be saying as the guys are getting suited up.
if the coach is worth a damn, he doesn't start pre-gaming until everyone is in the room.
no, this isn't the main problem at all. The fact that these girls have played on other teams with boys/men outside of the school league without any apparent problems would seem to put your arguments to rest.
the main problem is the impact this has on developing girls hockey programs, and also the BS stuff they sued for and won. Like the free lessons and money.
I've played on teams with girls, and it isn't a problem.
they don't shower and change in the same rooms. they dress in a seperate room and then join the team once everyone is in their equipment.
I wonder if I'm too crappy too play for the mens team if I get to play for the chick squad?
What a joke.
Decided to drop an email to the MHSAA and the Commission..............
Just wanted to drop a note of disappointment for the ruling against the MHSAA
As someone who has daughters, there is no reason for a school to allow players of the different sex to play on a team when they have one of their own.
If there was no female alternative to the male sport, then I agree that the girls be given opportunity to play in a male sport. My daughter made her high school boys football team here in Alberta. (Obviously no girls team.)
I am disappointed by the adjudicators assesment that the girls have the right to play to their skill level. This mentality is what inhibits the evolution of the women's game when all of the best players don't want to play with their same sex. How is there to be improvement in their game? Due to lack of participation is it OK that WKCI women's folds so Amy and Jesse could play with men?
I endorse equality. I endorse women having the same opportunity to play athletics as men. I endorse women playing on men's teams if they don't have an alternative for their own gender. I endorse when they have come to the end of their own gender amateur athletics to purse professional opportunities in their give sport regardless of gender. (Haley Wickenheiser in professional hockey playing with men.)
But this is none of those. This isn't discrimination, they CHOSE not to play for their women's teams. They CHOSE not to play minor hockey.
In my opinion, they are selfish, and that isn't what hockey is about.
George Bachul.
P.S. Calling the WKCI women's team a joke should point to the hypocrisy of the girls. (Talk about demeaning and disrespectful....the basis of which the damages against the girls were given.)