who's got more promise?

Status
Not open for further replies.

rinkrat13

Registered User
Nov 27, 2003
1,145
0
Toronto
Between the names below, who do you think has the most promise in the NHL and who has the least???

Senja, Semin, Vorobiev, Hudler, Michalek & Vanek

I would put them in this order:
1 Semin
2 Hudler
3 Sejna
4 Michalek
5 Vanek
6 Vorobiev

*of course I'm putting them in order of offensive upside, not all round ability*
 

pooler99

Registered User
Sep 28, 2002
665
0
Krynn
Visit site
rinkrat13 said:
Between the names below, who do you think has the most promise in the NHL and who has the least???

Senja, Semin, Vorobiev, Hudler, Michalek & Vanek

I would put them in this order:
1 Semin
2 Hudler
3 Sejna
4 Michalek
5 Vanek
6 Vorobiev

*of course I'm putting them in order of offensive upside, not all round ability*
As of now Vanek is the most promising he should be 1st in your list
 

Teemu

Caffeine Free Since 1919
Dec 3, 2002
28,753
5,227
1 Michalek
2 Vanek
3 Semin
4 Hudler
5 Vorobiev
6 Sejna
 

st_roland

Guest
X-SHARKIE said:
Agreed. Although I might have Sejna higher, Vanek lower.


ehh. I haven't watched sejna much, but I don't see how Vanek could be ranked higher than Semin. Hes been fantastic this season, and just scored his 3rd goal (7 points in 15 games so far)of the season so far. Butch Cassidy is a moron for scratching him so much. Hes really shown skill with the puck. I'd put him on top in terms of offensive upside and michalek on tops in terms of being the total player. Admittedly I havent seen much of the other players, but from what i've read, heard and the general sense I get on this board here are my rankings:


Semin-Flashy 1st line LW
Vanek-1/2nd line wing with copious skill
Michalek-Solid 2-way 2nd liner
hudler-Skilled 2nd line center/poss. 1st liner
Vorobiev-2nd liner/poss. 1st liner
Sejna-2nd liner
 

leafaholix*

Guest
1. Michalek
2. Vanek
3. Semin
4. Vorobiev
5. Sejna
6. Hudler
 

Patty Ice

Straight to the Banc
Feb 27, 2002
13,854
3,341
Not California
Outta all these guys, I think Michalek has the best all-around game but if we are goin strictly by offensive upside...Vanek ina walk.
 

Dr_Chimera*

Guest
I'd place Vanek first and Semin close behind. Both explosive offensive talents.
 

Jeffrey

Registered User
Feb 2, 2003
12,436
3
Montreal
Visit site
After last night game Habs vs Caps
I have to go with Semin !!!
what a player !!
he was BY FAR the best player on the Ice .. better than Jagr and Koivu ...
just amazing ...!!
and he's only 19 years old :eek: !
Good job to ''washington drafting squad'' for drafting him !!!
semin :bow:
 

Bandwagoner

Registered User
Nov 18, 2003
249
0
Canada
Visit site
Vanek
Michalek
Hudler
Semin
Sejna
Vorobiev

Though Michalek and Vanek can be interchanged, depending on what you're looking for. If you want offense, Vanek, however, if you want the more complete package, less offense but superb defense go with Michalek. I didn't really know how to rank the rest.
 

Biscuit Bullet

Registered User
Feb 28, 2002
6,423
2
Washington DC
Visit site
I think Semin has more promise than originally thought. I used to think he would max out as a second line 60 point scoring threat, but after seeing the ridiculous things he can do with the puck, I'm definitely beginning to think that he has 40 goal potential. He looks like a sturdier Chistov out there.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

-->