double5son10
Registered User
No chance in H-E-double hockey sticks that any of those three make the Hall. I think you could make an argument for Tonelli (two 2nd Team All-Stars, Canada Cup MVP, Selke finalist + big contributer to Calgary's '86 SC runner-up) and Goring (Smythe, Masterson, Byng) being in the Hall, though they wouldn't be strong inductions. Given all the carping about Gillies being in, I can only imagine the conniptions that would occur with either of Tonelli or Goring.
EDIT: I would also add that as to significance to the Isles dynasty of respective players, all of Morrow, Persson and Bourne were more important pieces than the three players mentioned in the OP.
EDIT: I would also add that as to significance to the Isles dynasty of respective players, all of Morrow, Persson and Bourne were more important pieces than the three players mentioned in the OP.
Last edited: