Which goal is nicer?
- Thread starter NYIschremp44
- Start date
- Status
Draft Guru
Registered User
They are both amazing.
Is Legg's goal something that is banned in the NHL? I have never seen a player attempt it before but I think it could be deadly if done correctly. Are players not allowed to carry the puck flat on their stick like that?
Is Legg's goal something that is banned in the NHL? I have never seen a player attempt it before but I think it could be deadly if done correctly. Are players not allowed to carry the puck flat on their stick like that?
Jeffrey
Registered User
I'd go with Hemmingways goal, just beacuse i think anybody that knows how to play hockey in the least could do what Legge did, i know i can do it, and i'm not great. Hemmingways is tough to do
Both are awesome, but I prefer Hemingway's goal for the only reason that I have never seen a goal like that anywhere else. A teamate of mine a few years ago scored a goal carrying the puck on his stick like Legge.
Ticallion961 said:
Seriously, i think you have them mixed up.
Hemingway's is doable, Legg's was downright incredible.
and i don't think anyone who knows how to play hockey "in the least" could do it
Ticallion961 said:
I also think you have them messed up. I've scored a goal like Hemmingway's before, its not all that hard. Leggs is more difficult and its harder to find a situation to do it.
Canadian Chris
Registered User
Legg's goal is near impossible, because it's so very seldom you'll get the time to flip it onto your stick, and be able to walk around enough to score.
Hemmingway's goal is doable, and has been done. Hell, I scored one like that the other night....but still impresseive to use in a game
Hemmingway's goal is doable, and has been done. Hell, I scored one like that the other night....but still impresseive to use in a game
Team_Spirit
95% Elliotte
- Jul 3, 2002
- 37,619
- 17,271
Draft Guru said:
No they can carry the puck over the shoulder anyways , i've seen Mats Sundin do it in a game when he was with the Nordique . It's was against Hartford in a Pre-Season game andQuebec was on the PP... Sundin did just like Legg but from the blueline to the net in one sweet motion ... Off course the goal wasen't good but i remember the face of my friend he was like 'whoa!'
Quagmier said:
Legg's goal is simple, its real easy to pick the puck up on your stick like that, doing it in a game situation takes a bit of balls, but easy none the less
Draft Guru said:
Legg's goal is a sign of unsportsmanlike. Legg received a verbal lashing by his coach after that goal. Did you know that Legg was benched rest of the game after that goal and he had to do sprints after it. Every guy in the nhl can do that if he wanted, but its unsportmanlike. Legg's goal was great no doubt, almost as nice as my pick up the puck and do a spinorama on a breakaway goal, but its classless to do in a game, practice is fine but not in a game. Where is Legg now? Playing Minors somewhere trying out new moves. Coaches dont tolerate that ****.
^^^^ That's a bunch of bull. You are right but it's too bad that people feel that way. How that goal is unsportsmanlike is beyond me.
Hemingway's goal is easy to do compared to Legg's.
Hemingway's goal is easy to do compared to Legg's.
both of them are a little too cocky for me
But Legg's seem to have more to do with actually scoring, the other one looks more like he just wanted to showboat
But Legg's seem to have more to do with actually scoring, the other one looks more like he just wanted to showboat
Ticallion961 said:
Haha, right, and Hemingway's is just so difficult to do.
as for the goals not being classy I don't understand where you guys are coming from. If you are running up the score, then as a team that is not classy, but to make nice moves like that and score fantastic goals that showcase your talent... well that's hockey last time I checked.
AJ1982 said:Haha, right, and Hemingway's is just so difficult to do.
as for the goals not being classy I don't understand where you guys are coming from. If you are running up the score, then as a team that is not classy, but to make nice moves like that and score fantastic goals that showcase your talent... well that's hockey last time I checked.
Then why did Legg's coach yell at him and bench him and make him do sprints? Answer that, im sayin both goals are great but that goal would never be done in the pros.
I like that Legge was benched for the goal. To me, carrying the puck in the air on your stick doesn't seem to be in the spirit of the game. Yzerman was asked about these kinds of goals and basically said, "neat trick but I'd never do it in a game".
Hemingway's goal was just as cocky if not more so, but all moves with the puck on the ice are fair game. I think that his move actually has some serious merit because it really sucks the goalie to one side and allows you to shoot the opposite way your body is travelling. It's kind of the same effect on a goalie as Forsberg's one-handed shoot out goal against Canada.
Despite all this if I was on the other team in either of these situations, I'd be seriously inclined to take off their heads next shift. But that's just me...
Hemingway's goal was just as cocky if not more so, but all moves with the puck on the ice are fair game. I think that his move actually has some serious merit because it really sucks the goalie to one side and allows you to shoot the opposite way your body is travelling. It's kind of the same effect on a goalie as Forsberg's one-handed shoot out goal against Canada.
Despite all this if I was on the other team in either of these situations, I'd be seriously inclined to take off their heads next shift. But that's just me...
Draft Guru said:
Yep, it's illegal to carry the puck AT ALL on your stick in the NHL. Denis Savard used to try it, and he'd get called for it every time. It's in the rulebook. You can slap the puck in the air (below the shoulder), but you cannot at any time carry the puck on the blade of your stick.
That's why Legg's goal-for as amazing as it was-would just be waved off in the NHL. However, Hemingway's goal, while pretty, is nothing new. I had teammates in high school do it, Mario Lemieux used to score this way once a year or so, and so on.
Legg's goal is way nicer then Hemmingways.
I've done Hemmingways goal in game, it really isn't that tough to do!!
Unbiased Canadian
I've done Hemmingways goal in game, it really isn't that tough to do!!
Unbiased Canadian
....
About NHL players trying something like Legge's goal...
Mike Comrie has tried it, and failed. The problem is that there just isn't enough time to do it in the NHL.
About NHL players trying something like Legge's goal...
Mike Comrie has tried it, and failed. The problem is that there just isn't enough time to do it in the NHL.
MartinStLouis said:
His coach is effin stupid!!!! If im not correct that won the game did it not? was it not the final? or semis? That is downright stupid coaching. Its like Crawford benching Naslund for scoring the goal he scored against Zac Bierk last year!
I still don't get why he would be benched. He scored a game winner and a sweet one at that. By all means necessary.
For anyone who has been around long enough, you'd remember when Gretzky pulled off a move similar to Legg's goal. Only difference is Gretzky did it on the other side of the net.. around the left post, not right..
Fedz said:
no it did not win the game, i have that game on tape and that goal tied the game at 3-3, Michigan later on went to score the 4th goal and win. His coach obviously doesnt want showboats on his team.
- Status
