TheRedressor
Registered User
- Oct 3, 2005
- 3,972
- 32
Greg7 said:Whoa, steep. You aren't getting a Crosby/Ovechkin type here, I don't think that sort of return is justified. Depending on who gets the pick on their plans/situation, it might take something like that to get it, but you'd be nuts to give that up imo.
I really don't want to get into a Kessel vs Crosby/Ovechkin debate, but I think a large majority of people would disagree with you, including me.TheChief said:I disagree, Kessel or Johnson are those types of talent.
TheChief said:I disagree, Kessel or Johnson are those types of talent.
thomasincanada said:
I disagree completely. I wouldn't trade Ovechkin or Crosby for the first two picks together this year.
GregStack said:Probably because you're not insane.
Kessel is a great young player, but I don't think he even comes close to equalling an Ovechkin, a Crosby, or a Malkin. If the team with the number one pick can find another team that thinks that highly of Kessel, I'd definitely trade that pick.
oil slick said:I don't know that it's insane to think that Johnson + Kessel = Crosby...
depends on whether you want one probable superstar or two probably elite players.
I don't know if I'd trade Hannan for the No. 1 pick right now. Hannan's a star defensive defencemen, one of the best shut-down defencemen in the game, and a guy whose value is at its peak in big games and in the playoffs, which is the hockey that truly counts.Mallard said:Sure, I'll try it out.
San Jose: Hannan, Goc, 2006 2nd Rounder
JF said:One of Rivet/Souray/Komisarek + either Perezhogin/Kostitsyn + our 1st round pick. And with that pick, I would draft Erik Johnson without thinking it twice.
I don't usually do trade offers, so I'm not really sure if I'm giving too much here or not enough...
nyhabsfan said:you'd give up two of our better prospects Komo and one of Perezhogin/Kostitsyn for a propsect (who has great upside) but hasn't played a game in the NHL?
Who are you; Reggie Houle's brother?
These 2 for 1 deals killed teh Hbas for 10+ years,... if you ever do this you must make SURE you get the best player in the deal, not trading for potential!!!
JF said:I'm sorry, but those are not the deals that killed us for ten years. Name me one time Houle tried or did obtain a number 1 pick in a draft. We're trading to draft a guy that is pretty much a lock to be playing in the NHL and has the potential to be a number 1 defenseman. You have to give something to get something. And I'm sorry, but to me, Johnson is the best player in the deal. We're giving potential for potential here (if they choose Komisarek in the deal). Neither Komisarek, Perezhogin or Kostitsyn have a secured spot on the team as far as I know.
So what do you think about the time when Andre Savard offered Garon, Zednik, Markov and 2 1st round pick (who were Komisarek and Perezhogin) to obtain the 2001 first pick overall (Kovalchuk). He must be another of Reggie Houle's brother too.
So instead of insulting me, why don't you make your "fair" proposal to obtain a number 1 pick overall. I would also like to get opinions from non-hab fans on my deal. I feel that the first round pick is maybe too much.
gars59 said:kessel is not kovalchuck .....
when he offered this
garon= goalie in ahl ... prospect
zednik: 20 goal year player ...
markov: a rookie , who don't speak english, and have problem of adaptation in north america 63-6-17-23
perezhogin+komisarek = prospect