What sort of return would be required to trade every player on the Leafs?

[Stand Witness]

Simple question, what would it take? Consider all factors you want.

Ex. Matt Hunwick is playing some very good hockey for his contract value. He would probably net a solid return considering he is barely making anything and has an extra year of term as well. Now is he worth more to the Leafs with his 2nd year option or is a pick worth more?

Here is a list of everyone who has played a game for the Leafs.

Rielly:
Bozak:
van Riemsdyk:
Phaneuf:
Lupul:
Komarov:
Parenteau:
Kadri:
Holland:
Winnik:
Boyes:
Mathias:
Gardiner:
Froese:
Polak:
Grabner:
Spaling:
Hunwick:
Harrington:
Marincin:
Arcobello:
Clune:
Reimer:
Bernier:

Click to read more...

 

[Stand Witness]

Rielly: Untouchable
Bozak: 2nd + 3rd
van Riemsdyk: 1st + top end prospect
Phaneuf: 1st
Lupul: 2nd + 2nd
Komarov: 2nd + decent prospect
Parenteau: 3rd (currently)
Kadri: 1st + top end prospect
Holland: 2nd
Winnik: 3rd
Boyes: 3rd
Mathias: 3rd
Gardiner: 2nd + 3rd
Froese: 5th
Polak: 4th
Grabner: 5th
Spaling: 4th
Hunwick: 2nd + 2nd (contract is a big part along with play)
Harrington: 3rd
Marincin: 6th
Arcobello: 7th
Clune: 7th
Reimer: 3rd
Bernier: 2nd

 

[Trapper]

Rielly: Untouchable
Bozak: 2nd + 3rd
van Riemsdyk: 1st + top end prospect
Phaneuf: 1st
Lupul: 2nd + 2nd
Komarov: 2nd + decent prospect
Parenteau: 3rd (currently)
Kadri: 1st + top end prospect
Holland: 2nd
Winnik: 3rd
Boyes: 3rd
Mathias: 3rd
Gardiner: 2nd + 3rd
Froese: 5th
Polak: 4th
Grabner: 5th
Spaling: 4th
Hunwick: 2nd + 2nd (contract is a big part along with play)
Harrington: 3rd
Marincin: 6th
Arcobello: 7th
Clune: 7th
Reimer: 3rd
Bernier: 2nd

What do you consider a top end prospect?
Who in the Leafs system do you consider a top end prospect?

 

[MJ65]

Simple question, what would it take? Consider all factors you want.

Ex. Matt Hunwick is playing some very good hockey for his contract value. He would probably net a solid return considering he is barely making anything and has an extra year of term as well. Now is he worth more to the Leafs with his 2nd year option or is a pick worth more?

Here is a list of everyone who has played a game for the Leafs.

Rielly:
Bozak:
van Riemsdyk:
Phaneuf:
Lupul:
Komarov:
Parenteau:
Kadri:
Holland:
Winnik:
Boyes:
Mathias:
Gardiner:
Froese:
Polak:
Grabner:
Spaling:
Hunwick:
Harrington:
Marincin:
Arcobello:
Clune:
Reimer:
Bernier:

Rielly - He is a keeper
Bozak - Atleast a 2nd round
van Riemsdyk - 1st rounder plus a prospect
Phaneuf - Not sure if he has any trade value (without some salary retention)
Lupul - We are stuck for at least another season or two
Komarov - We should keep him
Parenteau - would be happy with a 2nd rounder, if not a 3rd round pick
Kadri - We should try to sign him for another year
Holland - let him play for another season to find out how good he is
Winnik - Signed for another season, should keep him
Boyes -Not sure what's his trade value a 4th or 5th rounder
Mathias - same as Boyes
Gardiner - we should keep him
Froese - is there a trade value for him (6th / 7th rounder), if not then let him walk after this season
Polak: - Would be happy with a 3rd rounder
Grabner: Same as Boyes / Mathias
Spaling: same as Forese
Hunwick: a 2nd rounder
Harrington- still young, should keep him
Marincin: that's a tough one, I don't think if we are going to get much (still young)
Arcobello: Same as Forese / Spalling
Clune: Not sure
Reimer: If he continue the way he is playing, trade him for a 2nd rounder or keep him for now
Bernier: The way he is playing, we are stuck with him

 

[Stand Witness]

What do you consider a top end prospect?
Who in the Leafs system do you consider a top end prospect?

Something closer to the lines of Kapanen/Brown vs Marner/Nylander (blue chip).

 

[Trapper]

Something closer to the lines of Kapanen/Brown vs Marner/Nylander (blue chip).

So would you trade those guys plus a 1st for Kadri/JVR?
I wouldn't.

 

[cookie]

What do you mean by saying first? There's a lot of difference between the top 10 and the bottom 10. It would be better to say that Phaneuf will yield a playoff team's first rounder as opposed to just first. That leaves the next question: how many playoff teams are there that will take on the cap and term Phaneuf has? Cap dumps can alleviate that issue but then again, how many playoff teams have cap dumps that the Leafs are willing to take on?

 

[Stand Witness]

So would you trade those guys plus a 1st for Kadri/JVR?
I wouldn't.

If Anaheim offered us 1st + Ritchie for JVR or Kadri I would have to seriously consider it.

 

[Stand Witness]

What do you mean by saying first? There's a lot of difference between the top 10 and the bottom 10. It would be better to say that Phaneuf will yield a playoff team's first rounder as opposed to just first. That leaves the next question: how many playoff teams are there that will take on the cap and term Phaneuf has? Cap dumps can alleviate that issue but then again, how many playoff teams have cap dumps that the Leafs are willing to take on?

My intentions were more or less just from a base value that the player would have no really taking into account certain teams.

Realistically a late 1st or early 2nd + depending on the team but I cant see any bottom feeders picking up Phaneuf.

Sure a cap dump is probably required but that wasnt really my intentions. At this point I wouldnt trade Phaneuf for less than a 1st.

 

[Trapper]

If Anaheim offered us 1st + Ritchie for JVR or Kadri I would have to seriously consider it.

I'm sure if they did, they'd be gone already.

 

[champs*]

If Anaheim offered us 1st + Ritchie for JVR or Kadri I would have to seriously consider it.

not enough coming our way

 

[Canada4Gold]

Rielly: top 5 pick + top 10 D prospect+(not gonna happen)
Bozak: 2nd + 3rd
van Riemsdyk: 1st + good prospect + ecent prospect/roster player(Bobby Ryan trade mold)
Phaneuf: 1st
Lupul: 2nd
Komarov: 1st or 2nd+ good prospect
Parenteau: 3rd
Kadri: see JVR
Holland: 2nd
Winnik: 2nd + 3rd
Boyes: 4th
Mathias: 3rd
Gardiner: 1st + good prospect
Froese: 4th
Polak: 2nd
Grabner: 5th
Spaling: 3rd
Hunwick: 2nd + 3rd
Harrington: 2nd
Marincin: conditional 7th
Arcobello: see Marincin
Clune: 5 dollars
Reimer: 2nd
Bernier: 2nd

 

[2022 Stanley Cup]

Rielly: Untouchable
Bozak: 2nd + 3rd
van Riemsdyk: 1st + top end prospect
Phaneuf: 1st
Lupul: 2nd + 2nd
Komarov: 2nd + decent prospect
Parenteau: 3rd (currently)
Kadri: 1st + top end prospect
Holland: 2nd
Winnik: 3rd
Boyes: 3rd
Mathias: 3rd
Gardiner: 2nd + 3rd
Froese: 5th
Polak: 4th
Grabner: 5th
Spaling: 4th
Hunwick: 2nd + 2nd (contract is a big part along with play)
Harrington: 3rd
Marincin: 6th
Arcobello: 7th
Clune: 7th
Reimer: 3rd
Bernier: 2nd

Gardiner: 1st + decent prospect
Grabner: 3rd
Reimer: 1st (With the way hes been playing)
Bernier: 3rd (same reason)