Would a Vegas fan be able to rank and break down how good each defensemsn has played (so far)? I know it's a small sample size but I'm rather curious.
Also curious how you'd consider each guy compared to all D in the league ("this guy is a #4 on most teams...").
I'll take a stab at it.
Nate Schmidt: Honestly top marks should go to Colin Miller but for whatever reason, Gallant doesn't give him top ice time. In any case, Schmidt has greatly stepped up over how he played in preseason where he worried me significantly to the point where I asked in a post "why were Capitals fans so worried about losing Nate Schmidt?" he's involved at both ends of the ice in a big way. 7.5/10: playing like a good number 3 borderline #2
Colin Miller: Bit less of an offensive danger than Schmidt but I'd say he's been more reliable defensively than Schmidt.
7.5/10: playing like a good #3 borderline #2. Utilized like a bottom pair for reasons I can't fathom.
Jason Garrison/Deryk Engelland: both play solid enough defensively that they aren't noticed much so they're doing their job as bottom four defenders. Engelland's offensive production is really more incidental than anything.
7/10: playing like good #4/5 defenders
Brayden McNabb: mostly solid defensively, but has been exposed a few times
6.5/10 plays like a solid bottom pair
Luca Sbisa: Has as many strong defensive plays as bad ones. I can see where Canuck fans are coming from when they say he's improved but he's made some costly defensive errors.
6/10: plays like a bottom pair defender. If roster caps weren't a thing, Theodore could easily take a spot from him.
Jon Merrill: his defensive errors aren't as costly as Sbisa's but he's just not very strong at stopping plays or jarring the puck free defensively. At least Sbisa can get the puck out. Merrill at best knocks the puck free but it stays in the zone.
5.5/10 borderline bottom pair defender at the moment.
Won't rate Brad Hunt, Griffin Reinhart, or Clayton Stoner. Though I will say Reinhart should've been waived already. When he did play he was awful.