Proposal: Van- NYI Edler for #12 OA

[DekeyPete]

Quick and easy proposal. Straight up Edler to NYI, the #12 OA to Van.
Is this fair value? Do both teams do this?
And yes, of course Edler's NMC. But this is the internet, let's discuss.

Click to read more...

 

[wintersej]

Edler doesn’t have close to that value.

 

[seafoam]

Two 2nds, but it’s not like he’s waiving anyway.

 

[Gemel11]

No chance Edler is worth that much right now. Maybe back in 2012 when he put up 50 points

 

[Batrous]

Counter proposal: Islanders offer picks #41 (their 2nd) and Calgary's 2nd in 2019

Edit: For Edler

 

[SI90]

Lol no.

 

[Cogburn]

I'd add to Edler to get that first rather then take lesser picks, as two second round picks doesn't really do much for me. Edler is a better D then he was scoring 49 points a few years ago, but he's also older of course. He is our hands down best LD, and we have no one that is immediately ready to step in and take his minutes, as Juolevi has yet to make his debut.

If Edler and a small plus doesn't get us in range of that 1st, or something comparable, can we bring up Hutton for Nelson again? Or would Del Zotto interest you at all?

 

[Strait2thecup]

I'd add to Edler to get that first rather then take lesser picks, as two second round picks doesn't really do much for me. Edler is a better D then he was scoring 49 points a few years ago, but he's also older of course. He is our hands down best LD, and we have no one that is immediately ready to step in and take his minutes, as Juolevi has yet to make his debut.

If Edler and a small plus doesn't get us in range of that 1st, or something comparable, can we bring up Hutton for Nelson again? Or would Del Zotto interest you at all?

Hutton for Nelson just needs to happen already. I’d add to Nelson

 

[Newsworthy]

I'd add to Edler to get that first rather then take lesser picks, as two second round picks doesn't really do much for me. Edler is a better D then he was scoring 49 points a few years ago, but he's also older of course. He is our hands down best LD, and we have no one that is immediately ready to step in and take his minutes, as Juolevi has yet to make his debut.

If Edler and a small plus doesn't get us in range of that 1st, or something comparable, can we bring up Hutton for Nelson again? Or would Del Zotto interest you at all?

Rather just go after Demko because that's what the Isles need the most. And no Demko is not worth the 12OA

 

[Homesick]

Quick and easy proposal. Straight up Edler to NYI, the #12 OA to Van.
Is this fair value? Do both teams do this?
And yes, of course Edler's NMC. But this is the internet, let's discuss.

Not even close. You really think Lou Lam is going to trade 12thOA for a 32 year old 2nd pairing defenseman signed for one year?

 

[Qwijibo]

Edler? Alex Edler? For 12th overall? Uhm no. NYI will pass on that

 

[CodeE]

Treliving said the cost to trade into the 1st round is expensive, and costs a really good young player.

Trading into the high 1st with 32-year-old Edler? Doesn't seem very likely.

 

[boredmale]

How about Tanev and Elder for 12. lol

 

[Vorkosh]

How about Tanev and Elder for 12. lol

If we're gonna be crazy

Might as well make it Tanev, Edler Vancouver's 2nd 2019 (we don't have one this year) [compulsory 2nd round pick from Benning] and one of Kole Lind/Jonah Gadjovich for 11 and 12

Once that's done. Trade 11 and 12 to Ottawa for Karlsson and Ryan (which some sens fans have said they would be fine with) Bobby Ryan's contract must be included which is why NYI can't do this themselves if they're resigning Tavares as well

Lose Edler and Tanev

Gain Karlsson and one of Boqvist/Dobson/Bouchard/Hughes

all for the cost of a 2nd next year, Either Lind or Gadjovich and absorbing Ryan's contract.

Make Karlsson the obligatory Swedish captain in Vancouver. Done and done

 

[Shanejones]

If we're gonna be crazy

Might as well make it Tanev, Edler Vancouver's 2nd 2019 (we don't have one this year) [compulsory 2nd round pick from Benning] and one of Kole Lind/Jonah Gadjovich for 11 and 12

Once that's done. Trade 11 and 12 to Ottawa for Karlsson and Ryan (which some sens fans have said they would be fine with) Bobby Ryan's contract must be included which is why NYI can't do this themselves if they're resigning Tavares as well

Lose Edler and Tanev

Gain Karlsson and one of Boqvist/Dobson/Bouchard/Hughes

all for the cost of a 2nd next year, Either Lind or Gadjovich and absorbing Ryan's contract.

Make Karlsson the obligatory Swedish captain in Vancouver. Done and done

All joking aside, as a Nucks fan, I would do this in a heartbeat,hell,I’d even throw in taking back some of Edlers and Tanev salary, I’d say combined 25-30%

 

[M2Beezy]

Edlers best season in a while but he loves Vancity and wont wave. Would be a good deal but he wont do it

 

[Enrico Ciccone]

The time to trade Edler for any return at all was about 4 years ago....unless you call Pete Chiareli. Then you might get something good lol

 

[Vorkosh]

All joking aside, as a Nucks fan, I would do this in a heartbeat,hell,I’d even throw in taking back some of Edlers and Tanev salary, I’d say combined 25-30%

Problem is.. I don't think NYI fans will go for it haha.. although... I would be tempted/okay with throwing in our 2019 1st round pick as well.. IF Ottawa does the 2nd part of the trade

Defense of

Karlsson/Juolevi (perfect mentor)
Del Zotto/Bouchard(or Dobson)
Hutton/Stetcher

isn't too bad... and in 2 years with Tryamkin wanted to potentially come back.. it gets stronger..

 

[jay caufield forhead]

Counter proposal: Islanders offer picks #41 (their 2nd) and Calgary's 2nd in 2019

Edit: For Edler

this is alot closer to edlers value

 

[GoodbyeLuongo]

The time to trade Edler for any return at all was about 4 years ago....unless you call Pete Chiareli. Then you might get something good lol

He’s actually better now than he was 4 years ago

 

[Shanejones]

Problem is.. I don't think NYI fans will go for it haha.. although... I would be tempted/okay with throwing in our 2019 1st round pick as well.. IF Ottawa does the 2nd part of the trade

Defense of

Karlsson/Juolevi (perfect mentor)
Del Zotto/Bouchard(or Dobson)
Hutton/Stetcher

isn't too bad... and in 2 years with Tryamkin wanted to potentially come back.. it gets stronger..

Your hired

 

[Frankie Blueberries]

Lol no.

When this is the response from one of the more reasonable posters here, you know the value is pretty far off.
I do think Edler could fetch a late 1st though.

 

[Enrico Ciccone]

He’s actually better now than he was 4 years ago

Agree to disagree. Still has a good shot on the PP but no where near first round value

 

[Shanejones]

Your hired

He’s actually better now than he was 4 years ago

My feeling is, as a reasonable Nuck fan,that if we want to move Edler/Tanev, that the best easy is to package them, keep some salary and throw a 2nd round pick and prospect not named Pedderson,Brock, Gaudette or Demko and make sure you get a stud Dman and run to the draft and get BPA with the 7th pick

 

[SI90]

When this is the response from one of the more reasonable posters here, you know the value is pretty far off.
I do think Edler could fetch a late 1st though.

To be fair I do think Edler is worth a first but from the isles at 12 I don’t think that’s the deal for them. I’d rather re-sign DeHann and keep the first if Edler is the return. I’d rather package the 12th for a bit younger top pair Defensman. I view Edler as a #3/4

Sorry for my original reply. Didn’t mean to come off as a dick