Top 10 defensemen in 2007 NHL draft

[Redwingsfan]

I just like 9 defenceman better. it's more them moving up, then Ellerby moving down.

Alex Plante it too oaf-like for me. I've read his skating has really improved, but if it didnt I wouldnt want him in the sixth round. if he has improved greatly, but i'd probably put him 12 or 13 just because he's a dominating physical package, but since i haven't seen that myself, I can't put him on my list.

fair enough. i dont agree that he should be that low, but we all have our opinions

 

[haelwho]

you remember 19 player compairsons of the top of your head, but you dont remember the source

That list is from ESPN. Can't say I agree with some of the comparisons though, I prefer my list to that one.

 

[JeffShibley]

(1)Karl Alzner
(2)Nick Petrecki
(3)Thomas Hickey
(4)Ryan McDonagh
(5)Keaton Ellerby
(6)Mark Katic
(7)Kevin Shattenkirk
(8)Ian Cole
(9)Nick Ross
(10)Eric Doyle

what don't you like about blum?

 

[mikethompson]

yah no kidding he is top 5 on most lists i have seen, and he has never been rated below hickey from the lists i have seen i beleive.