Proposal: TJ Brodie for Eberle or Toffoli

[ConnorMcMullet]

Two teams that could use another top 4 defenseman for a right shot right winger that could be a great fit for the flames. Toffoli and Eberle are around the same age as Brodie and can put up 20 goals and 50 points. Would this work as a 1 for 1 deal?

Click to read more...

 

[Deen]

From a Flames fan, I would for sure do Toffoli for Brodie. Jeff Carter would be better though.

 

[blankall]

Not really interested in Eberle. Seems to soft. Also seems like the kind of player who won't have much use once he loses a step, which now that he's 28 could be anytime.

Toffoli I like though.

 

[Kale Hulls]

I think Toffoli would look good with Gaudreau, don't really think the Kings need defense though.

 

[Tkachuk Norris]

The Toffoi deal is not a bad deal. I just think we should consider trading Dougie for a bigger piece up front.

Hope TJ can refind his game beside Gio and then we would be scary. When Brodie is on his game, he is better than Hamilton.

If we add a good winger then Frolik and our young guys (Dube, Foo, Mangiapane, Janko and Bennnett) could really give us some guys that can actually chip in the odd goal in our bottom 6.

 

[Potty John]

Wouldn’t mind Toffoli at all for Brodie. But I do wanna see how whoever our new coach is will utilize Brodie.

 

[Lights911]

Not interested in moving Eberle atm

 

[herashak]

Brodie is not getting moved just for Eberle

 

[Kevin27NYI]

Not really interested in Eberle. Seems to soft. Also seems like the kind of player who won't have much use once he loses a step, which now that he's 28 could be anytime.

Toffoli I like though.

Eberle wasn't the most well received when he came to the Island but we love him now, I don't know if soft is the word to describe him. He's no Lucic but I don't think he's shy physically if that's what you're thinking. He engages and goes to the dirty areas, not like Lee or Simmonds but wouldn't have 60 points on a second line if he wasn't willing to earn it.

I'm not sure when he will lose his step either because he's smart and has incredible hands. I hope the Isles sign him to 5-6 years at the same price.

I would do this deal however. Same with Lee, Isles have offense and need defense. Asset wise for us it makes sense. Don't want to lose Eberle however, nor Lee.

I don't think it's a bad deal for the Flames, from that same angle they could afford to move a D for a RW, needs wise.

 

[KingCanadain1976]

La doesn't really need a defense man We are the team that gave up the least amount of goal in the nhl. We need more goal scoring and you want one of our best ones Yeah this makes a lot of sense........ NOT

 

[CREW99AW]

Eberle wasn't the most well received when he came to the Island but we love him now, I don't know if soft is the word to describe him. He's no Lucic but I don't think he's shy physically if that's what you're thinking. He engages and goes to the dirty areas, not like Lee or Simmonds but wouldn't have 60 points on a second line if he wasn't willing to earn it.

I'm not sure when he will lose his step either because he's smart and has incredible hands. I hope the Isles sign him to 5-6 years at the same price.

I would do this deal however. Same with Lee, Isles have offense and need defense. Asset wise for us it makes sense. Don't want to lose Eberle however, nor Lee.

I don't think it's a bad deal for the Flames, from that same angle they could afford to move a D for a RW, needs wise.

He provided a much better defensive effort then expected. His numbers were in line with usual production.

With his chemistry with Barzal,I would be ok if he signed an extension at his current salary.

 

[Kingspiracy]

Yeah, LA don't really need Dmen at the moment, we are light on scoring. If the flames are after Toffoli i'd ask for Bennet + back. Whether that works for the flames is another matter though.

 

[PWJunior]

Brodie is not getting moved just for Eberle

Calgary can have their 2019/2020 2nd rounder back too.

 

[Beautvillier]

the chia line remains on long island sry