hockeyscribe22 said:
But it would be a lot better if that happened in the NHL than in Europe simply because the NHL balked at a draft! My point is, they need Crosby now and shouldn't take any chances with this! They need him for marketing because let's face it, that has been one of, if no there greatest weaknesses!
Why? If he blows out his knee, he blows out his knee. Personally I think it would be a lot worse if the Crosby hype got to the NHL level and then this happened. In a lot of the US markets Crosby is still unknown (aside from the knowledgeable fans). Once the NHL comes back and a draft is set, the NHL-led Crosby hype machine is going to get into full gear. If you do that, lead the casual NHL fan to believe that one of the greatest of all-time is about to start up his career, and then he goes back into obscurity because he blows out his knee, then you have just left yourself with a big hole in your marketing campaign.
However, if it happens to him in Europe then there will be far less talk. The Crosby hypers (such as the ones on this site) will be left with "Crosby could have been great", but the NHL won't have to deal with the casual fan being pissed that they were hyped about some kid who never plays in a game.
Personally, as a leaf fan, it was like when Gilmour was brought back to the leafs from Montreal in his last season. And keep in mind that I am no where near enamoured with Doug as some others. Less than 5 years with a team should never, ever, qualify you as the greatest player for a team all-time. Best stint with a team, perhaps, but definately not best career.
Anyway, back to my point. When he was brought in, a lot of fans were ecstatic. Then he plays, and early on suffers a knee injury and he is done just as quick as he started. It would have been better had the trade never been made because it gave fans a false hope that Gimour might be able to recreate his playoff success (did pretty well with it in Montreal) and with a clearly superior team to the 93' team, a shot at a Cup. But all was not to be, and it left a bad taste in a lot of mouths.
I really can't see how it is better if he is brought in and then ushed out on crutches. Either way you lose him, but in the obscure option you don't have to deal with promising greatness to the normally uninterested fan.