Proposal: Shattenkirk to Toronto

[LT]

He’s a healthy scratch with a multi-year $6.65M contract, and you expect him to return a 1st and two decent prospects?

Yikes.

 

[Dr Pepper]

Would love to see the reaction from Nylander's agent if the Leafs made this move.

But I don't see it happening.

 

[The S5]

Agreed. Shattenkirk is far from the type of D man the Leafs need and he is way overpaid too!

McQuaid Claesson, Staal???
Wouldn't take much to get either of the first two. If you take Staal, we will hand deliver him to Toronto with the promise that he will resurrect his career, just like his brother, once he exits MSG!

 

[The List Of Jericho]

rumor is shatty is getting healthy scratched. The rangers are rebuilding and would probably just like to move on at this point. while shattenkirk isnt the defensive minded guy the leafs probably need, he would still be an upgrade. He would also give a big jolt to the 2nd unit PP (Marleau-Nylander- Johnsson- Gardiner-Shattenkirk)


Leafs: Shattenkirk
Rangers: 2019 1st rd pick, Borgman, Timashov

The Leafs need a guy that’s great defensivly...Shattenkirk ain’t it.

 

[Shootertooter]

He’s a healthy scratch with a multi-year $6.65M contract, and you expect him to return a 1st and two decent prospects?

Yikes.

He is likely scratched tonight for a game, lets not pretend he is going to be sitting for weeks or even days on end unless injured. This does not effect his trade value at this point.

 

[VoluntaryDom]

If we don't need the PP help, then why target a Shattenkirk type at all? I would think if the defensive players we target don't work out, we wouldn't then decide to target a different kind of player.

That’s a pretty elaborate way to call out a typo

 

[pheasant]

I would love Shattenkirk.

If Gardiner walks as a UFA after this season, that is. As of now, for this season, he would be too much of what we already have. He brings an element that, if anything, Toronto has too much of.

 

[bukwas]

Shattenkirk is a really easy pass.

 

[Halla]

Yep, in a non salary cap league...

they have the space this year. gardiner and hainsey walk freeing up 7+ and marleau is moved freeing up another 6.25

Cap probably going up 3-5 mil, they could fit him

 

[Halla]

Yeh, the Leafs can totally afford a near 7 mill add for a PP defenseman....

Shattenkirk + an ELC dman would only be a few hundred k more than Gardiner and Hainsey

 

[Toronto makebeleifs]

Don't say this often as I prefer to be constructive... that said, hard no. Do not want shatty at all.

 

[Halla]

he's a PP specialist and that's one of the last things the Leafs need. Astounded this was made by a Leafs fan. 6.65M cap hit and need to sign Nylander, Matthews and Marner, how is this going to work?

12 mil space

+

Gardiner and Hainsey walk
Marleau is moved to a cap floor team
Horton to LTIR when they are close to cap limit
=30.5 mil


Nylander 6.75
Matthews 11
Marner 8.25
shatty 6.65
= 32.65

they are a couple mil short but the cap is gonna be 83mil ish. maybe ask the rangers to eat 1.5-2, especially if he is just gonna be scratched

 

[Frelimo]

they have the space this year. gardiner and hainsey walk freeing up 7+ and marleau is moved freeing up another 6.25

Cap probably going up 3-5 mil, they could fit him

Have you heard of Matthews and Marner? Leafs can't be taking on bad contracts right now, especially for a guy they don't need.

 

[Claxton]

Shattenkirk has zero value right now. He needs alot more time to show he can recover from his knee problems, otherwise he'll be quickly entering Wade Redden territory.

 

[NoName]

This doesn't work without the Rangers retaining salary.

 

[HandshakeLineRespect]

Make this garbage thread go away.

 

[Colt55]

I still don't get the Shattenkirk hype, never did. He's a great tool in PP, but not a legit #1D. How will Toronto even manage to get under the cap if they add him? I just don't see him as a great fit.

He is not even legit #2 Dman parayko passed him up his rookie year. But got 50+ points

 

[DRW204]

12 mil space

+

Gardiner and Hainsey walk
Marleau is moved to a cap floor team
Horton to LTIR when they are close to cap limit
=30.5 mil


Nylander 6.75
Matthews 11
Marner 8.25
shatty 6.65
= 32.65

they are a couple mil short but the cap is gonna be 83mil ish. maybe ask the rangers to eat 1.5-2, especially if he is just gonna be scratched

and who do you replace Gardiner and Marleau with? Assuming Shatty is your replacement for Hainsey. And Marleau ddoes have a NMC, why waive when you're on a potential SC contender?

OP didnt have any mention of retained salary so that changes it a bit obviously. Doubt they'd eat 2M per year without more coming back though.

 

[Field of Dreams]

rumor is shatty is getting healthy scratched. The rangers are rebuilding and would probably just like to move on at this point. while shattenkirk isnt the defensive minded guy the leafs probably need, he would still be an upgrade. He would also give a big jolt to the 2nd unit PP (Marleau-Nylander- Johnsson- Gardiner-Shattenkirk)


Leafs: Shattenkirk
Rangers: 2019 1st rd pick, Borgman, Timashov

I presume you forgot to mention that Shatty is 50% retained?

 

[34]

This guy sucks, let's trade for him.

Yeah, no thanks.

 

[34]

He’s a healthy scratch with a multi-year $6.65M contract, and you expect him to return a 1st and two decent prospects?

Yikes.

No kidding.