Redraft 2003

[OttMorrow]

1. Zherdev
2. Phaneuf
3. Fleury
4. Staal
5. Parise
6. Horton
7. Michalek
8. Bergeron
9. O'Sullivan
10. Carter
11. Vanek
12. Coburn
13. Stewart
14. Suter
15. Kastsitsyn
16. Brown
17. Perry
18. Fehr
19. Eriksson
20. Poulliot
21. Mirnov
22. Getzlaf
23. Burns
24. Kesler
25. Nilsson
26. Eaves
27. Tambellini
28. Stuart
29. Belle
30. Locke

Let's see your redrafts!

Click to read more...

 

[PhoPhan]

I'll just do top 15.

MA Fleury
Dion Phaneuf
Nikolai Zherdev
Nate Horton
Eric Staal
Milan Michalek
Zach Parise
Anthony Carter
Patrice Bergeron
Jeff Carter
Patrick O'Sullivan
Ryan Suter
Braydon Coburn
Tomas Vanek
Dustin Brown

 

[Sabes]

1. Nikolai Zherdev
2. Eric Staal
3. Marc-Andre Fleury
4. Dion Phaneuf
5. Milan Michalek
6. Nathan Horton
7. Thomas Vanek
8. Braydon Coburn
9. Ryan Suter
10. Jeff Carter
11. Andrei Kostitsyn
12. Zach Parise
13. Ryan Getzlaf
14. Anthony Stewart
15. Dustin Brown
16. Mike Richards
17. Brent Seabrook
18. Brent Burns
19. Eric Fehr
20. Ryan Kesler
21. Patrice Bergeron
22. Mark Stuart
23. Steve Bernier
24. Marc-Antoine Pouliot
25. Robert Nilsson
26. Patrick Eaves
27. Patrick O'Sullivan
28. Shawn Belle
29. Hugh Jessiman
29. Corey Perry
30. Jeremy Colliton

That's just a quick list

 

[Prucha73]

1. Fleury
2. Zherdev
3. Phaneuf
4. Horton
5. Vanek
6. Michalek
7. Staal
8. Bergeron
9. Parise
10. Fehr
11. O'Sullivan
12. Coburn
13. Getzlaf
14. Suter
15. Brown
16. Perry
17. Richards
18. Stewart
19. Carter
20. Poulliot
21. Mirnov
22. Eaves
23. Fritsche
24. Kesler
25. Seabrook
26. Jessiman
27. Stuart
28. Belle
29. Locke
29. Baranka
30. Bernier

 

[monster_bertuzzi]

I'll just do top 15.

MA Fleury
Dion Phaneuf
Nikolai Zherdev
Nate Horton
Eric Staal
Milan Michalek
Zach Parise
Anthony Carter
Patrice Bergeron
Jeff Carter
Patrick O'Sullivan
Ryan Suter
Braydon Coburn
Tomas Vanek
Dustin Brown

Anthony Carter :lol

 

[Duff88]

1. Fleury
2. Zherdev
3. Phaneuf
4. Horton
5. Vanek
6. Michalek
7. Staal
8. Bergeron
9. Parise
10. Fehr
11. O'Sullivan
12. Coburn
13. Getzlaf
14. Suter
15. Brown
16. Perry
17. Richards
18. Stewart
19. Carter
20. Poulliot
21. Mirnov
22. Eaves
23. Fritsche
24. Kesler
25. Seabrook
26. Jessiman
27. Stuart
28. Belle
29. Locke
29. Baranka
30. Bernier

hmm... Kastsitsyn???

 

[Prucha73]

hmm... Kastsitsyn???

31. Kastsitsyn

 

[Seachd]

1) Staal
2) Zherdev
3) Fleury
4) Horton
5) Phaneuf
6) Vanek
7) Michalek
8) Parise
9) Suter
10) Getzlaf
11) Kastsitsyn
12) Carter
13) Fehr
14) Bergeron
15) Coburn
16) Pouliot
17) O'Sullivan
18) Brown
19) Stuart
20) Seabrook
21) Richards
22) Bernier
23) Kesler
24) Perry
25) Stewart
26) Nilsson
27) Eaves
28) Tambellini
29) Burns
30) Jessiman

 

[Duff88]

31. Kastsitsyn

Behind Locke and Baranka?

 

[KingPurpleDinosaur]

i said it before and ill say it again, i dont get exactly why parise shoots up to a top 10 pick after having a year that was worse then the previous. yes, i agree, he was picked late and deserved to go earlier, but he has done NOTHING to prove that he should be more highly touted then the year before, when he was drafted.

If anything, the place he was picked in 2003 was when his stock was highest. he didn't exactly make himself any better this year.

 

[Herby]

Maybe I'm a homer, but how does Brown fall after playing in the NHL and winning a bronze medal at the Senior WC?

I guess lighting up junior (Getzlaf, Carter, Richards, Perry etc) is more of an accomplishment than playing in the NHL?

 

[Herby]

BTW, here is mine

1. Nikolai Zherdev
2. Eric Staal
3. MA Fleury
4. Nathan Horton
5. Dion Phaneuf
6. Ryan Suter
7. Patrice Bergeron
8. Milan Michalek
9. Dustin Brown
10. Thomas Vanek
11. Jeff Carter
12. Zach Parise
13. Mike Richards
14. Ryan Kesler
15. Mark Stuart
16. Braydon Coburn
17. Eric Fehr
18. Brent Burns
19. Ryan Getzlaf
20. Brent Seabrook
21. Dan Fritsche
22. Anthony Stewart
23. Kevin Klein
24. Andrei Kastitstyn
25. Robert Nilsson
26. Patrick Eaves
27. Steve Bernier
28. Hugh Jessiman
29. Loui Eriksson
30. Josh Hennessey

 

[monster_bertuzzi]

31. Kastsitsyn

And where would you have Kesler? 54. ?

 

[Traitor8]

I don't understand how some of you don't even put Kostsitsyn in their list..other puts him in between 15 to 30..that is terrible. He should be top 10 , maybe 11th max.. and no way is Parise better then him

 

[Prucha73]

Behind Locke and Baranka?

What has he done so far besides getting very hot for a few WJC games? His size is average, and I am sure he is purely offensive player. Besides, it doesn't mean I am right, I could be wrong, and it doesn't mean he can't or won't be a vey good player

 

[Herby]

I don't understand how some of you don't even put Kostsitsyn in their list..other puts him in between 15 to 30..that is terrible. He should be top 10 , maybe 11th max.. and no way is Parise better then him

We've been over this before.

Look what Parise accomplished this season at UND and at the WJC. What did Kastitsyn accomplish this year?

 

[thestonedkoala]

Let's see what did O'Sullivan accomplish at the WJC and at Miss. this year

 

[Hossa]

Maybe I'm a homer, but how does Brown fall after playing in the NHL and winning a bronze medal at the Senior WC?

I guess lighting up junior (Getzlaf, Carter, Richards, Perry etc) is more of an accomplishment than playing in the NHL?

Jeff Carter and Anthony Stewart are two guys that could easily play in the NHL, yet didn't because of being on a very deep team (Carter) or not being able to get a contract (Stewart). Sometimes making the NHL at 18 isn't a matter of being the better prospect but having the better opportunity. Certainly Jason Spezza not playing in the NHL at 18 isn't a strike against him, while PM Bouchard and Brent Burns are better because of it.

When it comes to prospects, it's not about what level you are at as much as how you are progressing at the level where you are playing. Dustin Brown scored 1 goal this year (not including international play)...that isn't a good thing for his development.

Also it should be noted Brown is an 84 birthday and already had three OHL seasons under his belt. Stewart, Getzlaf, Carter, Perry and Richards- none of them had that luxury.

 

[Prucha73]

i said it before and ill say it again, i dont get exactly why parise shoots up to a top 10 pick after having a year that was worse then the previous. yes, i agree, he was picked late and deserved to go earlier, but he has done NOTHING to prove that he should be more highly touted then the year before, when he was drafted.

If anything, the place he was picked in 2003 was when his stock was highest. he didn't exactly make himself any better this year.

I think you are right, for some reason I thought he had higher numbers this season, and on top of that he has been twice outscored by his linemate Bochenski, so I guess I should have bumped him down by 7 or 8 spots.

 

[Hossa]

Lets see how this goes. I'm sure I missed somebody, but that's the beauty of the edit button.

1) Marc-Andre Fleury
2) Eric Staal
3) Nik Zherdev
4) Nathan Horton
5) Ryan Suter
6) Dion Phaneuf
7) Thomas Vanek
8) Braydon Coburn
9) Patrice Bergeron
10) Jeff Carter
11) Milan Michalek
12) Zach Parise
13) Anthony Stewart
14) Andrei Kastsitsyn
15) Dustin Brown
16) Mark Stuart
17) Ryan Getzlaf
18) Eric Fehr
19) Patrick O'Sullivan
20) Mike Richards
21) Brent Seabrook
22) Patrick Eaves
23) Steve Bernier
24) Brent Burns
25) Danny Fritsche
26) Ryan Kesler
27) Corey Perry
28) Corey Crawford
29) Robert Nilsson
30) Igor Mirnov

 

[montreal]

Kastitsyn accomplish this year?

He scored 25 goals in 27 games in the 1st league.

He helped his team win the Belarus Championship

He helped the U-20 team win their champhionship and return to the WJC's next year

He helped the Belarus National team win their champhionship and return to the WC's next year.

But that's just some silly facts, he only had 1 point in the RSL playing on the 4th line, so I guess the season was a waste.

 

[MichaelK]

What about Bruno Gervais? Nearly made the Islanders as a 6th Round draft pick

 

[Prucha73]

He scored 25 goals in 27 games in the 1st league.

He helped his team win the Belarus Championship

He helped the U-20 team win their champhionship and return to the WJC's next year

He helped the Belarus National team win their champhionship and return to the WC's next year.

But that's just some silly facts, he only had 1 point in the RSL playing on the 4th line, so I guess the season was a waste.

I did not see anywhere that he scored 25 goals in 27 games. Do you have a link for that?

 

[montreal]

I did not see anywhere that he scored 25 goals in 27 games. Do you have a link for that?

He had 38 points in 27 games for CSKA-2.

Can you read Russian, you don't need it but it helps. Goto cska.ru and look under cska-2, it has a box score for every game.

I wrote this article, which has all of his stats,

http://www.habsworld.net/show_big_news.php?id=369

 

[Freaky Habs Fan]

What has he done so far besides getting very hot for a few WJC games? His size is average, and I am sure he is purely offensive player. Besides, it doesn't mean I am right, I could be wrong, and it doesn't mean he can't or won't be a very good player

Yo.u base your list on stats right? You should base your list on high end potential...Kast dosen't had a real chance to show what he can do in the RSL. He was playing on the same team/same line then Zherdev and Nikolai wasen't puting better number on the CSKA fourth line so he should easily be in the top 15..see top 10!

And don't forget that he was on fire on CSKA-2...25 goals in 27 games isen't nothing in that league.