rate these prospects

[Habs33]

In terms of offensive abilities and upside:

T. Zajac
A. Kostitsyn
E. Fehr
B. Little
T.J. Oshie
J. Skille
D. Setoguchi
D. Stafford
A. Cogliano

Here's how I have their upsides:

Setoguchi
Little
Zajac

Kostitsyn
Skille
Fehr

Oshie
Stafford
Cogliano

Click to read more...

 

[Lars]

B. Little
D. Setoguchi
A. Kostitsyn
T. Zajac
T.J. Oshie
A. Cogliano
E. Fehr
J. Skille
D. Stafford

Based only on Offense.

 

[Talent Analyst]

A.Kostitsyn
...
Other

 

[s7ark]

B. Little
D. Setoguchi
A. Kostitsyn
A. Cogliano
T.J. Oshie
T. Zajac
E. Fehr
D. Stafford
J. Skille

I think Cogliano has a big upside. He just needs to mature physically a bit more. His speed and passing are excellent and his shot is above average.

I expect him to play a top 6 role in the NCAA this year and get a bit more PP time as well. He should put up some impressive numbers.

 

[Transported Upstater]

A.Kostitsyn
...
Other

How objective of you.


EDIT: This is tough, and I may be overrating Oshie's offense, but here's my list:

Little
Setoguchi
TJ Oshie
AK
E. Fehr
T. Zajac
A. Cogliano
J. Skille
D. Stafford

 

[Pete Rock]

How objective of you.


EDIT: This is tough, and I may be overrating Oshie's offense, but here's my list:

Little
Setoguchi
TJ Oshie
AK
E. Fehr
T. Zajac
A. Cogliano
J. Skille
D. Stafford

TU, your prospect knowledge is as brilliant as your choice of NFL teams. Note that there is NO sarcasm smilie.

I'm actually serious.

 

[Porn*]

B. Little
.D. Setoguchi
Cogliano
T.J. Oshie
A. Kostitsyn
J. Skille
D. Stafford
E. Fehr
T. Zajac

 

[EagleBelfour]

B.Little
T.J. Oshie
E. Fehr
J. Skille
A. Kostitsyn
T. Zajac
A. Cogliano
D. Setoguchi
D. Stafford

Only for offensive upside. Overall I put Setoguchi higher and Fehr and Kostitsyn lower.

 

[RightKinger]

Based on offense

Little
Kostitsyn
Zajac
Oshie
Setoguchi
Fehr
Skille
Cogliano
Stafford

 

[Habs33]

Hmmm...seems not everyone is sold on Cogliano as top 3.

Clearly I was only 'correct' about Stafford.

seems like the top 3 are Little, Kostitsyn and Setegouchi...

thx!

 

[HFNHL Canadiens]

Hmmm...seems not everyone is sold on Cogliano as top 3.

Clearly I was only 'correct' about Stafford.

seems like the top 3 are Little, Kostitsyn and Setegouchi...

thx!

Kostitsyn shouldn't be IMO

Offensive Potential

Setoguchi
Fehr
Little
Kostitsyn
Zajac
Cogliano
Oshie
Skille
Stafford

Chances of Busting

Skille
Cogliano
Kostitsyn
Little
Oshie
Zajac
Stafford
Setoguchi
Fehr

Overall

Setoguchi
Fehr
Little
Zajac
Oshie
Kostitsyn
Cogliano
Stafford
Skille

 

[NotStevenColbert]

Why does everyone hate Skille:
J. Skille: Anybody who thinks Kessel is an overhyped cry baby will always have a place in my heart.
B. Little: Small but mighty and his name suits him.
E. Fehr: Played pretty good in the AHL last year.
A. Cogliano: I have always liked him.
D. Setoguchi: I just like saying his name.
T.J. Oshie: He's pretty fast.
D. Stafford: Big guy.
A. Kostitsyn: dunno much about him but I have not heard good things.
T. Zajac: Just dont like him.

I really hate Zajac and really like Skille so I obviously put them where I them wanted to be not where they deserve to be.

 

[TaiMaiShu]

Why does everyone hate Skille:
J. Skille: Anybody who thinks Kessel is an overhyped cry baby will always have a place in my heart.
B. Little: Small but mighty and his name suits him.
E. Fehr: Played pretty good in the AHL last year.
A. Cogliano: I have always liked him.
D. Setoguchi: I just like saying his name.
T.J. Oshie: He's pretty fast.
D. Stafford: Big guy.
A. Kostitsyn: dunno much about him but I have not heard good things.
T. Zajac: Just dont like him.

I really hate Zajac and really like Skille so I obviously put them where I them wanted to be not where they deserve to be.

Thorough evaluation.

 

[Transported Upstater]

TU, your prospect knowledge is as brilliant as your choice of NFL teams. Note that there is NO sarcasm smilie.

I'm actually serious.

Thanks man.

 

[Jason MacIsaac]

Why does everyone hate Skille:
J. Skille: Anybody who thinks Kessel is an overhyped cry baby will always have a place in my heart.
B. Little: Small but mighty and his name suits him.
E. Fehr: Played pretty good in the AHL last year.
A. Cogliano: I have always liked him.
D. Setoguchi: I just like saying his name.
T.J. Oshie: He's pretty fast.
D. Stafford: Big guy.
A. Kostitsyn: dunno much about him but I have not heard good things.
T. Zajac: Just dont like him.

I really hate Zajac and really like Skille so I obviously put them where I them wanted to be not where they deserve to be.

Just currious how much hockey you have watched out of these players to complete your evaluation.

 

[TaiMaiShu]

Just currious how much hockey you have watched out of these players to complete your evaluation.

Prolly just did a quick scim through their HF profiles.

 

[Geogaddi]

A. Kostitsyn: dunno much about him but I have not heard good things.

I really hate Zajac and really like Skille so I obviously put them where I them wanted to be not where they deserve to be.

Yeah Kosty is pretty horrible. Can't even play hockey real good.