Rate these D's

[x-bob]

Rate these D's from BEst to worse

Vladimir Mihalik
Andy Rogers
Paul Ranger
Matt Smaby
Danny Richmond
Dmitri Vorobiev
Richard Petiot
Andrew Alberts
Brett Skinner
Matt Pelech

Click to read more...

 

[rt]

I'd take Richmond out of that group, but I don't know enough to rank them.

 

[Erik]

Rate these D's from BEst to worse

Vladimir Mihalik
Andy Rogers
Paul Ranger
Matt Smaby
Danny Richmond
Dmitri Vorobiev
Richard Petiot
Andrew Alberts
Brett Skinner
Matt Pelech

Lotsa Lightning guys on there, so thats all I can really comment on...

Right now:

Ranger
Rogers
Mihalik
Smaby

Potential:

Rogers
Mihalik
Smaby
Ranger

 

[x-bob]

Ok how about to change the question a bit....who is the best?

 

[Vatican Roulette]

Rate these D's from BEst to worse

Andrew Alberts
Paul Ranger
Andy Rogers
Richard Petiot
Danny Richmond
Vladimir Mihalik
Matt Smaby
Dmitri Vorobiev
Matt Pelech
Brett Skinner

Mihalik is ranked low just because the % of success with drafting for the 2nd Chara, or huge guys overall. Skinner, never really liked him. Pelech is ranked low because of of his injury history. Every scouting report had a big question mark to go along with it.