With all of these comparison threads around I wanted to ask around for an opinion on who will be the better all around player between the 2 most highly touted 2nd overall selections in recent memory. Who will be better offensively and on D? What are each guys max NHL scoring potential and who does Malkin most resemble in today's NHL? Would you trade one for the other straight up? Will either match Heatly in terms of scoting? Let the debate begin!