Pogge vs Rask vs Scneider

[Bryzga lol*]

Poor Pogge, such is life being a Leafs prospect. Win almost every award available and still can't get any respect.

Maybe Rask and Schneider would have won those awards in the same league

 

[Charge_Seven]

Maybe Rask and Schneider would have won those awards in the same league

Ah yes, the old "maybe" comparison.

I guess the possibility that Schneider could have won awards makes him better than Pogge.

In fact...if I was in the same league I could have won an award too...

New list...

1-Stack
2-Rask
3-Pogge
4-Schneider

 

[mooseOAK*]

Maybe Rask and Schneider would have won those awards in the same league

Who knows, but the only one that did in recent memory was Cam Ward.

 

[reidy]

No respect? Pretty sure that's Pogge on HF's Top 50, not Schneider.

Poor Schneider, such is the life of an American prospect. Put up very similar numbers to Pogge in a superior league and still get no respect.

 

[Rabid Ranger]

No respect? Pretty sure that's Pogge on HF's Top 50, not Schneider.

Poor Schneider, such is the life of an American prospect. Put up very similar numbers to Pogge in a superior league and still get no respect.

Schneider's "lack of respect" stems more from the league he plays in rather than his nationality (IMO). Personally, I don't mind people saying that Rask or Pogge are better prospects, just don't add the ridiculous "I've hardly seen any of Schneider."

 

[Leaf Army]

homer?? or did you just turn the list upside down

1.rask
2.schneider
3.pogge

Very funny. But not true.

I liked Pogge better even when they were both Leaf prospects so there goes that theory of yours. I also correctly predicted that the Leafs would trade Rask before Pogge.

For some reason Rask's stock went through the roof over the summer.

 

[Oedi]

Very funny. But not true.

I liked Pogge better even when they were both Leaf prospects so there goes that theory of yours. I also correctly predicted that the Leafs would trade Rask before Pogge.

For some reason Rask's stock went through the roof over the summer.

the old "overrated leaf prospect" theory huh?

 

[Transported Upstater]

Ah yes, the old "maybe" comparison.

I guess the possibility that Schneider could have won awards makes him better than Pogge.

In fact...if I was in the same league I could have won an award too...

New list...

1-Stack
2-Rask
3-Pogge
4-Schneider

Stack is STACKED!!!!

 

[Leaf Army]

the old "overrated leaf prospect" theory huh?

Does this somehow relate to something I said?

 

[Mr. Hab]

90-95% of GM's would take them in this order...

1. Rask
2. Schneider
3. Pogge

 

[BuppY]

90-95% of GM's would take them in this order...

1. Rask
2. Schneider
3. Pogge

I don't think so.

1. Rask
2. Pogge
3. Schneider

 

[Sebastien Centomo]

Rask and Schneider << Pogge and Raycroft


I'd take Rask & Schneider anyday over Pogge & Raycroft.

So why are you saying Raycroft and Pogge are greater than Rask and Schneider?

 

[Geese_Howard*]

So why are you saying Raycroft and Pogge are greater than Rask and Schneider?

Cause everyone is better then the leafs to that habs homer.... why would you compare 2 goalies from difference oraganizations to the leafs?

I swear, the difference between rask and pogge is slim to say the least, schneider is just behind them..... they are all rather close, we're not comparing Broduer to Yann Denis.... all 3 are close, how you list them is really by personal preferences.

For the record, as a leaf fans, I put Rask #1 slighly ahead of Pogge, Pogge can surpass him if he does well in the AHL.

 

[Charge_Seven]

90-95% of GM's would take them in this order...

1. Rask
2. Schneider
3. Pogge

You must have had a nice talk with them, you're so deeply knowledgeable of what nearly all of the GMs in the league would do.

 

[VanW27]

For some reason Rask's stock went through the roof over the summer.

i noticed that too, somehow without playing any hockey Rask managed to become a better prospect over the summer.

I wonder what happened in the summer?

 

[shakes]

For some reason Rask's stock went through the roof over the summer.

Odd I know.. I wonder why that is?

 

[Charge_Seven]

i noticed that too, somehow without playing any hockey Rask managed to become a better prospect over the summer.

I wonder what happened in the summer?

Well, around hockeys future, his stock skyrocketed as soon as he was traded.

But he really is the superstar prospect he's made out to be, and he SHOULD be in the top ten list sometime in the near future (next season).

 

[Leaf Army]

You must have had a nice talk with them, you're so deeply knowledgeable of what nearly all of the GMs in the league would do.

You'd be hardpressed to find much of anything that 95% of GMs in the league would all agree on let alone this topic.

 

[Charge_Seven]

You'd be hardpressed to find much of anything that 95% of GMs in the league would all agree on let alone this topic.

No, Mr Hab said it, it's true. Don't question him.

 

[LeafDangler]

right now I'd say that regardless of skill Pogge has the best chance of becoming a starting NHL netminder. Rask is beside an even better goaltending prospect in Toivenen and Schnieder is behind one of the best goalies in the world in Luongo. It seems the leafs have put all their eggs in one basket so to speak with Pogge. Keep in mind this is a somewhat biased view.

 

[VanW27]

right now I'd say that regardless of skill Pogge has the best chance of becoming a starting NHL netminder. Rask is beside an even better goaltending prospect in Toivenen and Schnieder is behind one of the best goalies in the world in Luongo. It seems the leafs have put all their eggs in one basket so to speak with Pogge. Keep in mind this is a somewhat biased view.

i dont think its biased, regardless of who anyone thinks is better i dont think many would argue against Pogge having his path to the NHL laid out for him, as a result he should see NHL game time first possibly 3/4 years before Rask.

 

[Redwingsfan]

Very funny. But not true.

I liked Pogge better even when they were both Leaf prospects so there goes that theory of yours. I also correctly predicted that the Leafs would trade Rask before Pogge.

For some reason Rask's stock went through the roof over the summer.

lol. i was just kidding. these goalies are so close that you have to be top scout to really tell who is the best. all these lists are just persional opinions from non-scouts. and maybe everyone is wrong, maybe schneider turns out to be the best of the three. you just never know.

 

[Transported Upstater]

Well, around hockeys future, his stock skyrocketed as soon as he was traded.

But he really is the superstar prospect he's made out to be, and he SHOULD be in the top ten list sometime in the near future (next season).

Truthfully, when I saw that Rask was ranked as high as he was, I was shocked (SHOCKED!!!). I didn't think he was at THAT level whether he was our property or not.

 

[Plato]

rask

 

[RSBPC]

Being a Bruins and BC Eagles fan, I didn't want to throw my list up here just to be accused of blatant homerism, but it seems like most people would agree with me anyways.

Rask>Schneider>Pogge.