Please rank these prospects

[Helmethead]

A Kostitsyn
A Semin
B Burns
R Kesler
C Higgins
R Whitney
F Tjutin
M Komisarek
R Hainsey
R Suter
B Coburn
Thanks

Click to read more...

 

[CH Wizard]

Komi isn't a prospect.

That's my ranking anyways.

B Coburn
A Kostitsyn
R Suter
F Tjutin
R Kesler
A Semin
C Higgins
R Hainsey
R Whitney
B Burns
M Komisarek I ranked him last because he isn't a prospect.

 

[Testify]

same for A Semin.. HF has him as graduated from the Caps' prospect list.

but I pretty much agree with the list of thegreatone without Semin there

 

[TomahawkSniper]

Komi isn't a prospect.

That's my ranking anyways.

B Coburn
A Kostitsyn
R Suter
F Tjutin
R Kesler
A Semin
C Higgins
R Hainsey
R Whitney
B Burns
M Komisarek I ranked him last because he isn't a prospect.

Looks good to me, but I would put Whitney in front of Hainsey.

 

[CH Wizard]

Looks good to me, but I would put Whitney in front of Hainsey.

Yep you're right sorry.Because I am still high on Hainsey.Whitney is still young.Hainsey isn't very young for a prospect but I am sure next year Hainsey gonna wakeup and put good numbers.Because it's his last chance ! I still considere Hainsey a better prospect now.But if next year he won't respond I am gonna put Whitney in front of Hainsey Without a DOUBT !

 

[eddy]

Coburn
Kostitsyn
Komisarek
Suter
Tjutin
Whitney
Kesler
Semin
Higgins
Hainsey
Burns

 

[Duff88]

B Coburn
R Suter
A Kostitsyn
F Tjutin
C Higgins
R Kesler
R Whitney
B Burns
R Hainsey

 

[montreal]

A Kostitsyn

B Burns
R Kesler
C Higgins
R Whitney
F Tjutin

R Hainsey
R Suter
B Coburn
Thanks

Kostitsyn
Tjutin
Suter
Higgins
Coburn
Kesler
Burns
Hainsey
Whitney

 

[velimiiro]

Kostitsyn
Tjutin
Suter
Higgins
Coburn
Kesler
Burns
Hainsey
Whitney

i agree with everything on that list.

dunno what you other guys were thinking with Coburn at #1...??!


EDIT: the only change i would make is putting Burns infront of Kessler.

 

[CH Wizard]

i agree with everything on that list.

dunno what you other guys were thinking with Coburn at #1...??!


EDIT: the only change i would make is putting Burns infront of Kessler.

We aren't the only persons who put Coburn high on a list.Hockeyfuture rank him at 10th (2 spot in front Kost).I agree that Kost upside is huge.But Coburn is a huge with some skills but he play a excellent defensive game.If he reaches all of his potential he can become one of the most dominant and solid D in the NHL.Kost can become one of the most explosif forward and he has a lot of skills.But for me and some other persons Coburn should be in front of Kost.

 

[Stanger31]

A Semin
F Tjutin
R Suter
A Kostitsyn
B Coburn
M Komisarek
B Burns
R Kesler
R Hainsey
R Whitney
C Higgins

 

[db23]

It is impossible to rank a group of players who are so different in age, position, style etc. They all bring something different to the game. You need a big strong defenceman as much as you need a slick playmaking centre, or a goalscorer on the wing, a powerplay QB, a grinding defensive forward...etc., etc.

 

[Rowsdower]

R Suter
B Coburn
A Kostitsyn
F Tjutin
C Higgins
R Whitney
R Kesler
B Burns
R Hainsey

 

[BigAl]

A Kostitsyn
A Semin
B Burns
R Kesler
C Higgins
R Whitney
F Tjutin
M Komisarek
R Hainsey
R Suter
B Coburn
Thanks

Well Sean, I don't think you can win a hockey pool with bums like these.....