One Year Ago, the Florida Panthers Fired Gerard Gallant

Ziggy Stardust

Master Debater
Jul 25, 2002
63,046
34,004
Parts Unknown
Shortly after Thanksgiving of last year, the Florida Panthers relieved head coach Gerard Gallant, and their then, highly unqualified general manager, Tom Rowe, stepped in as interim head coach.

Fast forward to today, where Gallant has taken an expansion team and as of today, is coaching the best team in the Western Conference, with the second best overall record in the NHL.

Meanwhile, the Panthers are among the worst teams in the league and will be looking at a lottery selection as they have the 8th worst record in the league.

Not only is the disparity between the two teams a testament to Gallant's abilities as a head coach, but it also brings to attention that the Panthers firing Gerard Gallant may have been the most misguided coaching decision a hockey club has made in recent memory. And they made that call two months into a season after Gallant was named a finalist for the Jack Adams Trophy.

At the time of his firing, Pierre LeBrun wrote the following:
Fired Florida coach Gerard Gallant deserved better

The response I got to Gallant's firing from team executives and coaches around the league was a universal shaking of the head. A coach who was nominated for the Jack Adams Award last season is gone just 22 games into the 2016-17 campaign -- while his team is over .500 and has battled key injuries since the get-go.

The fact that photos surfaced of Gallant having to hail his own cab in Raleigh, North Carolina, after being told he was fired -- well, that just adds to the level of outrage for many.

I suspect that Gallant knew he was on the clock from the moment former GM Dale Tallon was "promoted" to president of hockey operations last spring. Gallant had been Tallon's coach. And now Tallon had been punted from the day-to-day hockey decision-making.

You can't fire a coach right after he has been nominated for coach of the year, can you? But the Panthers canned Gallant. For no justifiable reason.


Surely, this has to rank up there as one of the most misguided and ill informed coaching decisions in recent memory.
 
Last edited:

tony d

Registered User
Jun 23, 2007
76,590
4,550
Behind A Tree
He's done quite good for sure, always questioned why Florida would fire Gallant, the job he is doing in Vegas is amazing, he should be the unaminous Adams award winner at this point.
 

BruinLVGA

CZ Shadow 2 Compact coming my way!
Dec 15, 2013
15,187
7,325
Switzerland
If Gallant isn’t the run away coach of the year candidate, I don’t know who should be. Top coach.
 

Taro Tsujimoto

Registered User
Jan 6, 2009
15,306
7,488
Clarence Center, NY
rsUVypg.jpg

Goofus make poor personnel decisions that hurt his team in the long run.

RkRkwti.jpg

Gallant is now the head coach of one of the top teams in the NHL.
 

swimmer77

More PIM's than Points
Jun 22, 2010
6,674
2,140
in water
Remarkable story really. I was aware of the success Gallant was having in Florida but became a "fan" of his, if you will, after he was fired. Thought he handled the situation with class.
He certainly has persevered and good for him.

I keep waiting for VGK to show sign(s) of weakness but they just don't do it. Florida really shot themselves in the foot and it is too bad because it seemed they were turning the corner. I'm truly happy for Gallant and the success he is having.
 

Howboutthempanthers

Thread killer.
Sponsor
Sep 11, 2012
16,405
4,146
Brow. County, Fl.
Saw this whole situation coming from a mile away when I first learned that ownership was interfering with hockey decisions. Which happened to me in the 2016 offseason (the actually interference had started in the middle of the 2015-2016 season, which I totally believe lead to them losing in the first round playoffs to the Islanders). If you want an explanation as to why the Panthers stay bad for 2 decades, just look no further than the actions of their current ownership throughout that whole situation.
And as bad as that is, what's even more amazing to me is that some people still defend this decision and think Gallant is a mediocre coach.
 

Matti_A

Registered User
Sep 21, 2005
2,023
167
Interesting how things change, around the time Gallant was fired by the Blue Jackets back in '06 I recall the consensus on hfboards was that he was the worst coach in the league.
 

Uncle Scrooge

Hockey Bettor
Nov 14, 2011
13,479
8,022
Helsinki
The team had just won 6 out of their last 10 games and was beating some good teams, like Montreal (league leading team at the time), Columbus (breakout year), Rangers (one of the hottest teams of the first half) and Tampa (with Stamkos still).

And they didn't even have Huberdeau.
 

CuriousGeorge

Registered User
Jun 8, 2007
1,530
492
Shortly after Thanksgiving of last year, the Florida Panthers relieved head coach Gerard Gallant, and their then, highly unqualified general manager, Tom Rowe, stepped in as interim head coach.

Fast forward to today, where Gallant has taken an expansion team and as of today, is coaching the best team in the Western Conference, with the second best overall record in the NHL.

Meanwhile, the Panthers are among the worst teams in the league and will be looking at a lottery selection as they have the 8th worst record in the league.

Not only is the disparity between the two teams a testament to Gallant's abilities as a head coach, but it also brings to attention that the Panthers firing Gerard Gallant may have been the most misguided coaching decision a hockey club has made in recent memory. And they made that call two months into a season after Gallant was named a finalist for the Jack Adams Trophy.

At the time of his firing, Pierre LeBrun wrote the following:
Fired Florida coach Gerard Gallant deserved better

The response I got to Gallant's firing from team executives and coaches around the league was a universal shaking of the head. A coach who was nominated for the Jack Adams Award last season is gone just 22 games into the 2016-17 campaign -- while his team is over .500 and has battled key injuries since the get-go.

The fact that photos surfaced of Gallant having to hail his own cab in Raleigh, North Carolina, after being told he was fired -- well, that just adds to the level of outrage for many.

I suspect that Gallant knew he was on the clock from the moment former GM Dale Tallon was "promoted" to president of hockey operations last spring. Gallant had been Tallon's coach. And now Tallon had been punted from the day-to-day hockey decision-making.

You can't fire a coach right after he has been nominated for coach of the year, can you? But the Panthers canned Gallant. For no justifiable reason.


Surely, this has to rank up there as one of the most misguided and ill informed coaching decisions in recent memory.
It was the worst mistake in the last five years.
 

Fatty McLardy

Registered User
Oct 6, 2017
4,243
3,693
I still remember going why the hell? when they fired him. A guy that takes you to the playoff in god knows how long, sweet justice for Gallant as his team is one of the best and Florida is back in the basement.
 

ShootIt

Registered User
Nov 8, 2008
17,804
4,583
He's done quite good for sure, always questioned why Florida would fire Gallant, the job he is doing in Vegas is amazing, he should be the unaminous Adams award winner at this point.

He hated that they traded off Gudbranson and wanted Logan Shaw to make the roster. When injuries happened, instead of calling up Shaw, they traded him off for Sgarbossa.

He did embrace some of their analytics but wasn't a fan of their offseason and was vocal about it to them.
 

PanthersPens62

Coach Nerd
Mar 7, 2009
21,215
3,644
Mike's Wheel Barrell
Saw this whole situation coming from a mile away when I first learned that ownership was interfering with hockey decisions. Which happened to me in the 2016 offseason (the actually interference had started in the middle of the 2015-2016 season, which I totally believe lead to them losing in the first round playoffs to the Islanders). If you want an explanation as to why the Panthers stay bad for 2 decades, just look no further than the actions of their current ownership throughout that whole situation.
And as bad as that is, what's even more amazing to me is that some people still defend this decision and think Gallant is a mediocre coach.

Those people who defend the decision are called "stat nerds" and is why I have little to no time for that nonsense. Give me someone like Gallant who does not swear by advanced stats any day of the week & twice on Sundays.
 

RainingRats

Registered User
Dec 28, 2008
21,649
4,797
You can also thank Tallon for giving Gallant, March and Smith for a 4th. Those two guys have certainly helped Vegas get to where they are.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

-->