Proposal: Oil/Pens/Flames

[Sparky93]

Oiler In: Letang($7.25 millio)
Oilers Out: Klefbom, Puljujarvi or Klefbom, Yamamoto + 10th OA($5.095 million)

Pens In: Hamilton, Puljujarvi or (Yamamoto + 10th OA) + Frolik($10.975 million)
Pens Out: Letang + Kessel($14.05 million)

Flames In: Kessel + Klefbom($10.97 million)
Flames Out: Hamilton + Frolik($10.05 million)

Click to read more...

 

[Tapdog]

Your a Flames fan right?

 

[Starat327]

Oilers are getting bent hard.

Like, no dinner, no lube, and no cab ride home hard.

 

[Empoleon8771]

The Penguins get roasted in this, dear lord. Flames come out like bandits. Edmonton also loses this pretty badly.

 

[Ragdoll]

Jeez the Oilers get f***ed so bad.

Must be a flames fan.

 

[Taytro]

Wow no from Edmonton.

 

[TFHockey]

Oiler In: Letang($7.25 millio)
Oilers Out: Klefbom, Puljujarvi or Klefbom, Yamamoto + 10th OA($5.095 million)

Pens In: Hamilton, Puljujarvi or (Yamamoto + 10th OA) + Frolik($10.975 million)
Pens Out: Letang + Kessel($14.05 million)

Flames In: Kessel + Klefbom($10.97 million)
Flames Out: Hamilton + Frolik($10.05 million)

That's a steep price coming from Edmonton. Then the Pens turn around and get Hamilton with those assets? And Klefbom ends up a Flame? Nah. Oilers pass.

Also: Pens must take on more salary, not Edmonton.

 

[Empoleon8771]

That's a steep price coming from Edmonton. Then the Pens turn around and get Hamilton with those assets? And Klefbom ends up a Flame? Nah. Oilers pass.

Also: Pens must take on more salary, not Edmonton.

The Penguins are already giving up Kessel and Letang, why do you want to make the deal worse for them?

 

[Jumptheshark]

Oiler In: Letang($7.25 millio)
Oilers Out: Klefbom, Puljujarvi or Klefbom, Yamamoto + 10th OA($5.095 million)

Pens In: Hamilton, Puljujarvi or (Yamamoto + 10th OA) + Frolik($10.975 million)
Pens Out: Letang + Kessel($14.05 million)

Flames In: Kessel + Klefbom($10.97 million)
Flames Out: Hamilton + Frolik($10.05 million)

Easy no from the oilers

 

[TFHockey]

The Penguins are already giving up Kessel and Letang, why do you want to make the deal worse for them?

Well I guess my point was Edmonton is giving up a rich haul and taking on more salary which they can't afford.

Yeah the Pens by the end are losing a ton.

 

[CaptainCrunch67]

Calgary passes. they can probably get someone more in their age window with a less expensive contract for Hamilton alone.

 

[Sparky93]

That's a steep price coming from Edmonton. Then the Pens turn around and get Hamilton with those assets? And Klefbom ends up a Flame? Nah. Oilers pass.

Also: Pens must take on more salary, not Edmonton.

I don’t know, a #3/4 Defenseman + a very high end prospect for a bonified #1 RH defenseman, locked up for another 4 years, seems about right. You can say Letang isn’t the guy because of age but you’d be hard pressed to find better for the price.

 

[WeWentBlues]

Oilers getting bent over pretty hard. I actually think the Penguins make out okay on this trade.

Oilers In: Letang + Tkachuk

That's still not quite even.

 

[CF84]

Oilers getting bent over pretty hard. I actually think the Penguins make out okay on this trade.

Oilers In: Letang + Tkachuk

That's still not quite even.

Gross. I'm not justifying the original deal, but Tkachuk+Hamilton for Klefbom+Kessel is absolutely disgusting.

 

[rent free]

maybe if chiarelli was the manager of both edmonton and pittsburgh would this happen

 

[Volica]

I'll give it a try, because I was legitimately thinking of a three way with these three teams, with Pens playing the facilitator for the two AB rivals:

Oiler In: Andersson, Letang
Oilers Out: Puljujarvi, 10th OA, Zack Kassian

Pens In: Brodie, Frolik, Zack Kassian, 10OA
Pens Out: Kessel, Letang

Flames In: Kessel, Puljujarvi
Flames Out: Andersson, Brodie, Frolik

Thought process:
Edmonton gets a top pairing PMD & top 4 prospect with great upsde.
They Lose: #10 pick, A top pick from 2 years ago draft with high potential, and Zack Kassian (cap thing)

Pens get a top 3 guy, who can play on the top pair and has no issues playing 26+ minutes a night, they get a swing winger in Frolik who can play up and down the lineup and have no issues with it, they get some major toughness with decent skills in Kassian, they get the 10OA at the draft to pick up someone like Ferabee or Veleno, who could play in the NHL sooner rather than later on an ELC (because Malkin/Crosby can shelter). They also open up 5 million in cap space. Also get back into a high pick, something they've missed for a bit now.
They Lose: A great D in Letang, a great winger in Kessel.

Flames get: A top RW right now, a winger with some potential that's had a hard time putting it together.
They Lose: A top 3 guy, their top prospect, a dependable RW.

 

[Skobel24]

I'll give it a try, because I was legitimately thinking of a three way with these three teams, with Pens playing the facilitator for the two AB rivals:

Oiler In: Andersson, Letang
Oilers Out: Puljujarvi, 10th OA, Zack Kassian

Pens In: Brodie, Frolik, Zack Kassian, 10OA
Pens Out: Kessel, Letang

Flames In: Kessel, Puljujarvi
Flames Out: Andersson, Brodie, Frolik

Thought process:
Edmonton gets a top pairing PMD & top 4 prospect with great upsde.
They Lose: #10 pick, A top pick from 2 years ago draft with high potential, and Zack Kassian (cap thing)

Pens get a top 3 guy, who can play on the top pair and has no issues playing 26+ minutes a night, they get a swing winger in Frolik who can play up and down the lineup and have no issues with it, they get some major toughness with decent skills in Kassian, they get the 10OA at the draft to pick up someone like Ferabee or Veleno, who could play in the NHL sooner rather than later on an ELC (because Malkin/Crosby can shelter). They also open up 5 million in cap space. Also get back into a high pick, something they've missed for a bit now.
They Lose: A great D in Letang, a great winger in Kessel.

Flames get: A top RW right now, a winger with some potential that's had a hard time putting it together.
They Lose: A top 3 guy, their top prospect, a dependable RW.

Value wise, very well done!

 

[Sparky93]

I'll give it a try, because I was legitimately thinking of a three way with these three teams, with Pens playing the facilitator for the two AB rivals:

Oiler In: Andersson, Letang
Oilers Out: Puljujarvi, 10th OA, Zack Kassian

Pens In: Brodie, Frolik, Zack Kassian, 10OA
Pens Out: Kessel, Letang

Flames In: Kessel, Puljujarvi
Flames Out: Andersson, Brodie, Frolik

Thought process:
Edmonton gets a top pairing PMD & top 4 prospect with great upsde.
They Lose: #10 pick, A top pick from 2 years ago draft with high potential, and Zack Kassian (cap thing)

Pens get a top 3 guy, who can play on the top pair and has no issues playing 26+ minutes a night, they get a swing winger in Frolik who can play up and down the lineup and have no issues with it, they get some major toughness with decent skills in Kassian, they get the 10OA at the draft to pick up someone like Ferabee or Veleno, who could play in the NHL sooner rather than later on an ELC (because Malkin/Crosby can shelter). They also open up 5 million in cap space. Also get back into a high pick, something they've missed for a bit now.
They Lose: A great D in Letang, a great winger in Kessel.

Flames get: A top RW right now, a winger with some potential that's had a hard time putting it together.
They Lose: A top 3 guy, their top prospect, a dependable RW.

That is terrible value for the Pens!

 

[GOilers88]

So the Oil send out Klefbom, Pulju, Yama, and the 10th, and all they get is Kris Letang?

Am I missing something?

 

[Volica]

So the Oil send out Klefbom, Pulju, Yama, and the 10th, and all they get is Kris Letang?

Am I missing something?

We're also going to need you to send McDavid out as well.

 

[GOilers88]

We're also going to need you to send McDavid out as well.

Throw in an old Matt Stajan jersey and you have a deal.

 

[Volica]

Throw in an old Matt Stajan jersey and you have a deal.

Best part. UFA, that's free money baby.

 

[The Moose is Loose]

The Penguins get roasted in this, dear lord. Flames come out like bandits. Edmonton also loses this pretty badly.

The penguins definitely don't get bent here. They do okay on this trade

 

[Sparky93]

So the Oil send out Klefbom, Pulju, Yama, and the 10th, and all they get is Kris Letang?

Am I missing something?

Original proposal was Klefbom + Puljujarvi or Klefbom, Yamamoto + 10th OA

 

[ThePhoenixx]

How long do the Oilers have to try and clone Klefbom?