All 30 teams would be financially healthy? Nashville looks good. Pittsburgh came an eyelash from moving. Lots of teams, including Buffalo who sells out every game, need a self imposed cap in order not to lose money.
The problems in Pittsburgh and Nashville started
well before this CBA. Let's not pretend that things were fine in those two cities pre-CBA, and then all the damage was done in 2 years because of this new agreement. The Pens were teetering because of an
incredibly bad lease and a completely apathetic city and state who refused to give the team a 2nd chance at a new arena for free (something the Pirates and Steelers got). The Predators were in trouble b/c Leipold & Co. kicked sand in the eyes of the corporate community early on, and companies withheld their $ for luxury boxes, premium seating, etc. as a result.
All of that had
nothing to do with this CBA.
Buffalo and Tampa are having problems keeping their stars? For the 11,672nd time ... the purpose of the salary cap system is
NOT for all teams to spend as much as possible - it's for all teams to spend to the midpoint. Without the cap system, Buffalo never has to worry about making a choice of whether to keep Drury or Briere - because in the old system, Buffalo doesn't get revenue sharing and thus doesn't have the money to worry about keeping either guy; they're both long gone.
No, under the current system teams are on nearly the same playing field - so teams with payrolls of $34 million have about the same chance of winning the Cup as teams with payrolls of $50 million, and teams raking money in hand over fist have to (gasp!) actually share some of that money with teams who have no hope of being in that position and would struggle to stay afloat (and ice a halfway competitive team) without revenue sharing. Yes, that means having to make choices - but
everyone will have to make those choices. A team like Edmonton
really can compete for the Cup again with a $35 million payroll and not have to worry about Detroit and Colorado spending $80 million (or more) and snapping up key guys like a collector perusing the latest offerings from the Franklin Mint.
Eventually, we'll see parity in the league like we've seen in the NFL - the franchises that are really good and know how to plan ahead will rise to the top, and the franchises that have no clue how to go about business will sink to the bottom, and teams will generally have legitimate hopes of going from out of the playoffs to in the playoffs in a year or two, not 4-7 years like we saw pre-CBA.
And when it happens ... that will be a
good thing.