Nylander vs Mackinnon

[Cousin Eddie]

Similar age (8 months in difference)
Similar stats
Both forwards

Who do you take?

P.S. If you're a Leafs fan/Avs fan please select that option. It's pretty embarrassing when somebody with the name AVALANCHEFANFOREVERANDEVER votes for their player in the non-fan section.

Click to read more...

 

[Makar Goes Fast]

mackinnon, he does it himself

 

[firstemperor]

MacKinnon, now and future.

 

[bob27]

This shouldn't even be close. MacKinnon vs Matthews would be more relevant comparison.

 

[Cousin Eddie]

This shouldn't even be close. MacKinnon vs Matthews would be more relevant comparison.

Nylander beat Mackinnon in this very poll during the summer. It hasn't changed that much since then.

 

[Jarey Curry]

Nylander beat Mackinnon in this very poll during the summer. It hasn't changed that much since then.

yeah but masses are asses, this summer the poll was a forward with upswing team and good rookie season vs a forward with historically bad team. It was no big picture poll if Nylander swept Mack's nose then

 

[Not My Tempo]

Leaf fan saying MacKinnon. I’m slightly biased as MacK is my favourite player in the league

 

[Tavares to Marner]

Mackinnon easily

 

[1967th Heaven]

MacKinnon

 

[Ainec]

Nylander beat Mackinnon in this very poll during the summer. It hasn't changed that much since then.

Nylander hype from Leafs fans were absurd over the summer. Getting paragraph responses when I ask how he's better than Pastrnak was fun

I can't believe everything I've said in the off-season came to fruition
-Nylander & Marner overhyped
- Zaitsev overrated
-Kadri real deal
-Rielly & Andersen underrated

 

[IPS]

Nylander now and future. Mackinnon ain't on his level, simple as that.

 

[Our Lady Peace]

Nylander now and future. Mackinnon ain't on his level, simple as that.

Can you riddle us why? Or is that far beyond your obvious agenda of posting controversial opinions here?

 

[webersshot]

This is a dumb poll....Mackinnon vs Matthews should be the poll, but i suppose thats kinda pointless cause theirs obviously more leafs fans than avs on here so we know how that would go don't we lol

 

[webersshot]

Nylander now and future. Mackinnon ain't on his level, simple as that.

lmao

 

[missionAvs]

Avs fan voting for MacK. I just feel like MacK is the man driving the offense more often. Even last year on a historically bad Avs team, he managed to put up respectable numbers. That said, I think Nylander is a great young player. If you wanted to compare him to anyone on the Avs, I think the adequate guy would be Rantanen.

 

[Pierce Hawthorne]

This is a dumb poll....Mackinnon vs Matthews should be the poll, but i suppose thats kinda pointless cause theirs obviously more leafs fans than avs on here so we know how that would go don't we lol

Not much point to put a Matthews vs. anybody poll really. Even versus McDavid I think Leafs fans would still outweigh all the Oilers fans and other fans that actually cared enough to vote.

 

[PinkFly]

This is a dumb poll....Mackinnon vs Matthews should be the poll, but i suppose thats kinda pointless cause theirs obviously more leafs fans than avs on here so we know how that would go don't we lol

Not much point to put a Matthews vs. anybody poll really. Even versus McDavid I think Leafs fans would still outweigh all the Oilers fans and other fans that actually cared enough to vote.

Matthews is also better than MacKinnon in almost every single facet of ice hockey. Its not fair to Mackinnon to be compared to the far superior Matthews.

 

[Wrath]

Matthews is also better than MacKinnon in almost every single facet of ice hockey. Its not fair to Mackinnon to be compared to the far superior Matthews.

Ok you don't have to go full hyperbole in the other direction. Mackinnon is better at some things than Matthews (like say, skating speed).

I'm an Avs fan and I'd take Matthews over Mackinnon every day of the week too.

 

[StatisticsAddict99]

Mack, AINEC... Remember when Nylander was the most hyped young gun on the boards, turns out every non-leaf fan was right, he’s just getting overrated and overhyped, he’s good but simply not Elite..Flash in the pan. Next please.

 

[ChasmOfFire]

MacKinnon

 

[dellzor]

Anyone who says Nylander is a Leafs fan

 

[Chef de Cuisine]

MacKinnon AINEC

 

[DDRhockey]

Mack, AINEC... Remember when Nylander was the most hyped young gun on the boards, turns out every non-leaf fan was right, he’s just getting overrated and overhyped, he’s good but simply not Elite..Flash in the pan. Next please.

Speaking of flash in the pan. Isnt that exactly what mackinnon has been last two seasons prior to this one?

Nylander beat him in points last season

 

[VoluntaryDom]

MacKinnon

 

[Spilot23]

Can you riddle us why? Or is that far beyond your obvious agenda of posting controversial opinions here?

Sergachev should turn out as a top pairing guy. Risto a 2nd pairing PP specialist. And Provorov a 2nd/3rd pairing guy.

[mod] I saw this in the poll Provorov vs Sergachev vs Ristolainen (future) when Provorov is already a top pairing Dmen