Value of: NYI - WPG

[Dano85]

To WPG: Pulock, 1st (NYI or CGY)
To NYI: Trouba

Would this deal make any sense? does Trouba want to play in WPG? Is the value way off? The Isles look like they could use some right now D help and Trouba seems more ready for that then Pulock (whats his long term outlook)

although I am sure the Jets would prefer to keep Trouba if they wanna go for it this season.

Click to read more...

 

[Kcb12345]

To WPG: Pulock, 1st (NYI or CGY)
To NYI: Trouba

Would this deal make any sense? does Trouba want to play in WPG? Is the value way off? The Isles look like they could use some right now D help and Trouba seems more ready for that then Pulock (whats his long term outlook)

although I am sure the Jets would prefer to keep Trouba if they wanna go for it this season.

Jets fans won't like this. They need Trouba just as much as the Isles do (maybe not as much, but they need him). And in a contending season, I can't see them making a move like this

 

[Dano85]

Jets fans won't like this. They need Trouba just as much as the Isles do

Yeah I believe that, I tried address it in the OP.

 

[DRW204]

This won't end well

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

To WPG: Pulock, 1st (NYI or CGY)
To NYI: Trouba

Would this deal make any sense? does Trouba want to play in WPG? Is the value way off? The Isles look like they could use some right now D help and Trouba seems more ready for that then Pulock (whats his long term outlook)

although I am sure the Jets would prefer to keep Trouba if they wanna go for it this season.

Winnipeg is better then the Islanders, No way is Chevy dealing Trouba for what you're offering.

 

[CuriousGeorge]

To WPG: Pulock, 1st (NYI or CGY)
To NYI: Trouba

Would this deal make any sense? does Trouba want to play in WPG? Is the value way off? The Isles look like they could use some right now D help and Trouba seems more ready for that then Pulock (whats his long term outlook)

although I am sure the Jets would prefer to keep Trouba if they wanna go for it this season.

The value is off for sure.

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

Jets fans won't like this. They need Trouba just as much as the Isles do (maybe not as much, but they need him). And in a contending season, I can't see them making a move like this

That package not even close for Trouba.

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

This won't end well

Agreed it's pretty bad from a Jets point of view.

 

[Dano85]

Winnipeg is better then the Islanders, No way is Chevy dealing Trouba for what you're offering.

just wanna put it out there I am not an Isles fan, I asked in the OP if the value was way off. Do you think they could be trading partners? and what else would be required...

 

[ichabod13]

what is trouba looking for contract wise?
and pulock is done for the year.....( shoulder injury ) then he is off to free agency. so you would only be getting a first round pick for trouba.

 

[Dano85]

Agreed it's pretty bad from a Jets point of view.

I thought it may be thats why I asked if the value was even close? what more do you think it would require?

Thread was mostly based on a couple Jets fans post in one of my other threads where they seemed some what unsure how things would go with Trouba in the off season

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

just wanna put it out there I am not an Isles fan, I asked in the OP if the value was way off. Do you think they could be trading partners? and what else would be required...

Yeah the value is definitely way off, Not sure if the Isles or Jets make good trading partners at least not for Trouba the asking price would definitely be Barzal at least.

 

[Dano85]

what is trouba looking for contract wise?
and pulock is done for the year.....( shoulder injury ) then he is off to free agency. so you would only be getting a first round pick for trouba.

didnt even realize he was done for the season (you sure thats not Dehaan) definitely makes this a no go. was just thinking 2 RFA one from Manitoba one who seems like he would rather play in the states same age both Righties...

 

[Dano85]

The value is off for sure.

you seem like a good poster, but you always leave me wanting more, seen a few of your posts where you just post statements but no solutions. what would you require/expect

 

[Number1RedWingsFan52]

what is trouba looking for contract wise?
and pulock is done for the year.....( shoulder injury ) then he is off to free agency. so you would only be getting a first round pick for trouba.

Depending on the team i could see Trouba getting a similar deal as Cam Fowler so 7 or 8 years around $6.5 million per would be my guess. Obviously 8 from Winnipeg 7 from the rest of the league.

 

[CuriousGeorge]

you seem like a good poster, but you always leave me wanting more, seen a few of your posts where you just post statements but no solutions. what would you require/expect

Thanks for the compliment. I appreciate being called a good poster. As for the trade, the value is off because Islanders is giving too much with first rounder in a deep draft and a quality defenceman for another quality defenceman.

 

[ichabod13]

didnt even realize he was done for the season (you sure thats not Dehaan) definitely makes this a no go. was just thinking 2 RFA one from Manitoba one who seems like he would rather play in the states same age both Righties...

you are right it is de haan......my mistake.
from an islanders standpoint, i say "sure, why not?"
from a winnipeg standpoint, i say "no thank you."

 

[Dano85]

Thanks for the compliment. I appreciate being called a good poster. As for the trade, the value is off because Islanders is giving too much with first rounder in a deep draft and a quality defenceman for another quality defenceman.

hmmm seems like you are the only one who thinks this deal is in the Jets favor, as noted in the OP I am not 100% certain of the expectations surrounding Pulock

 

[SLAPSHOT723]

Isles fan saying yes. Pulock will be a good NHL defenseman though.

 

[Dano85]

Isles fan saying yes. Pulock will be a good NHL defenseman though.

what would you say his ceiling/comparables are?

 

[broc]

Thanks for the compliment. I appreciate being called a good poster. As for the trade, the value is off because Islanders is giving too much with first rounder in a deep draft and a quality defenceman for another quality defenceman.

No, the value is off bc Pulock is not worth close to Trouba, and the 1st is not enough to change that.

 

[Hunter368]

No thx from jets

 

[SLAPSHOT723]

what would you say his ceiling/comparables are?

I think his ceiling is Justin Faulk. He may not get there, but I think that's a solid comparable if he puts it together.

I don't want to give up Pulock, but I really like Trouba.

 

[Dano85]

I think his ceiling is Justin Faulk. He may not get there, but I think that's a solid comparable if he puts it together.

I don't want to give up Pulock, but I really like Trouba.

thanks.

Jets off season should be interesting they have 8 RFAs.

 

[Dano85]

No thx from jets

Not related to the OP trade but how much you think the Jets RFAs sign for?

Trouba
Morrissey
Poolman

Lowry
Armia
Tanev
Dano

Helly

then next year
Connor
Laine

Thanks