Injuries in brawls are set at 1 percent?
I guarantee if you ask any baseball fan that is a non jays fan whose fault this was, they side with the Yankees here every single time. If he was told to intentionally hit Donaldson he sure made it look like he didn't mean to. It barely grazed him, on his pad. But it was intentional? The evolution of a brawl, when it actually happens, is to defend your team mates regardless of it being right or wrong. You think the royals want to defend Ventura all the time for being an idiot? Probably not, but they do it because that's what team mates do. So it doesn't matter how they all felt about it, they rushed in to protect their guys.
And no, every other team would not have. It was a nothing play. Like I said earlier, I'm all for defending your guys. You have to. But doing so in this situation is no Bueno.