McDavid vs Scheifele
- Thread starter Skolman
- Start date
- Status
Scheifele - brings a similar stature of game at less than half the cost.
McDavid is the better player though overall.
McDavid is the better player though overall.
Except McDavid nearly doubles Scheifele point total this past season.
And I like Scheifele but this is McDavid, even factoring in contracts.
Scheifele was hurt, but lets not take that into account.
McDavid is extremely overrated on HF.
Scheifele out scored McDavid in 2015-16.. Clearly hes the better player.. Wait Mcdavid was hurt.... oh okay that makes sense... Logical approach bud, try again harder next time.
not sure how a player achieving goals on a tier that has only Gretzky and Lemieux makes one overrated.
seems he's rated just fine.
kylbaz
Winnipeg <3
McDavid is obviously the choice here but it's pretty stupid to say he nearly doubled his point total considering Scheif was a ppg player at 60pts in 60 games.
Scheifele was hurt fir 1/4 of the season. If he plays a full season he gets 80 points and makes half the money mcdavid does.
This same poll was locked a few days ago after McDavid won in a landslide. As he should have
So still a 30 point gap with Scheifele in his prime and McDavid still with room to grow.
Some people need to get over the idea that someone needs to have double the points to be worth double the salary. Having players in a higher tier is simply harder to find and it's often worth the extra money even if their affect on the team isn't as evident in their point total advantage. Would anyone seriously take Rakell over Scheifele for instance? His deal is just over 60% of the cap hit of Scheifele's and he's scored at just under 80% of his PPG the last two years combined (just under 90% this year)
scheifele isn't in his prime yet, he's just entering it. he also plays with spectacular wingers. i'm not so sure mcdavid will have the talent around him to make his point totals higher to a certain enough point where he'd be definitely more valuable.
McDavidCrushedLarkin
Registered User
- Jun 12, 2016
- 4,320
- 2,413
McDavid and this isn't even close.
Scheifele is a tier below McDavid but above the Laine/Matthews/Eichel tier.
Scheifele is a tier below McDavid but above the Laine/Matthews/Eichel tier.
Back to back Art Ross trophies and somehow he's EXTREMELY OVERRATED.
Which is kinda funny coming from a guy with Matthews in his user name.
Scheifele is 25 and has been a PPG player for two years. He's smack dab in the prime for most players, and while I wouldn't be surprised if he has a spike season in terms of points, it's unlikely he's going to significantly improve as a player in any meaningful way at this point.
Also, why would Scheifele's wingers helping his point totals be part of Scheifele's value and not the value of those wingers? If anything it shows that the gap between him and McDavid is larger than the point totals appear.
tony d
Registered User
snipes
How cold? I’m ice cold.
- Dec 28, 2015
- 54,960
- 61,628
Back to back Art Rosses by 21 years old.
Only two people in the 100 year NHL history have done that: Gretzky and McDavid.
But yeah, extremely overrated you say.
The fact you cant pick up on sarcasm is hystrerical
The fact you cant pick up on sarcasm is hystrerical
It was the name I was born with. I wouldn't be talking if my name was TAD.
Coming from a guy who's name is one syllable i cant take you seriously. But yeah McDavid is extremely overrated. Not even PPG in the playoffs.
Hard core EDM fan... Obviously biased. You probably think Talbot is an all star and Larson is a 1D.... Thats why Hall is getting more Hart votes then McOverrated.
Last edited:
nickdawg95
scoutdawg
- Jan 7, 2016
- 3,285
- 1,769
- Status
