Unless someone was actually posting in 2012 saying that Bishop should be our goalie of the future and he is the most talented out of Anderson and Lehner, and that if we trade him it will blow up in our faces, I cannot take seriously the hindsight GM type posts about us keeping Bishop.
Bishop had played only THIRTY NHL games. The fact that he could have been had for value around a second round pick, yet teams weren't lining up to grab him shows that Ottawa wasn't the only team who missed the boat on Bishop's potential. What people are suggesting is that Ottawa should have traded arguably the best starter they've ever had other than Hasek who prior to being injured was having an elite year in an attempt to bet on a goalie who played 30 career games. All the while, Anderson at the time was still young, and the Senators had a blue chip goalie prospect in Robin Lehner already coined as the goalie of the future.
Again, if someone was posting in 12-13 about how big of a mistake trading Bishop would be, and about how he is going to be a Vezina contender and one of the best goalies in the league, respect to them for getting it right. But the captain hindsight GM stuff is just lame. Ottawa made a HUGE mistake trading a goalie like Bishop to a division rival for Conacher, there is no discounting that. But almost nobody thought it was a mistake at the time.