Kevin27NYI
Registered User
- Aug 5, 2009
- 19,710
- 5,764
Well im glad the 1st and the prospect dont matter to you to much...cause quite honestly i wouldnt do the trade with them. Hamonic OR Pulock (with POSSIBLY a pick involved as well). Do we think Duchene is better than Hall? And by how much would ya say? Would love to Duchene in an Islanders uniform but think Barzal/Pulock+Hamonic + 1st rounder is obsurd. Hall for Larsson straight up but Duchene is gonna cost what????
Hall and Duchene have the same value roughly, and Larsson was a proven top pairing shutdown player at that time. Hamonic is more of a #3D and plays on the right side and would be behind our two best Dmen. We need a LD not a RD. And Pulock while having decent upside isn't a top pairing guy, and you'd be getting Duchene who's a #1C or #1W. There's risk in trading Duchene for no guranteed NHL player.
Did you really just call Larsson a proven top pairing?
Yeah at this point I can't wait to see him traded to see what the value is.