Both young defencemen, Matt is born september 25 1984, drafted second round #47 overall. 6 feet tall and 190 pounds. He did great 12 games that year in San Jose. I except a great career for him. In playoff in did not so bad, he made some mistake in the second round, but he was nice to see. Mathieu Carle a little bit younger, born in september 30, in 1987. Drafted in second round #53 overall. So he's 18 but not for long. 6'00 feet tall and 210 pounds, he got great offensive upside for this age, put 69 points in 67 games at Bathurst. I know they're not at the same level, but they got nearly the same name, both defencemen, and they are similar on body built, both was drafted in second round. At this point Matt Carle is better IMO, he prove's he can play at NHL level, and did nice play. Who you think who gonna get more sucess ?