Marner or Hischier

[Brobust]

First 20 games

Mitch Marner - 7 goals, 9 assists - 16 points (13 5v5, 3 PP)
Nico Hischier - 3 goals, 12 assists - 15 points (11 5v5, 4 PP)

The fact that this isn't 50/50 or in Marner's favour due to his longer track record is telling about this site's bias against Leafs players.

 

[Snippit]

First 20 games

Mitch Marner - 7 goals, 9 assists - 16 points (13 5v5, 3 PP)
Nico Hischier - 3 goals, 12 assists - 15 points (11 5v5, 4 PP)

The fact that this isn't 50/50 or in Marner's favour due to his longer track record is telling about this site's bias against Leafs players.

Hischier is two years younger...

 

[bsu]

First 20 games

Mitch Marner - 7 goals, 9 assists - 16 points (13 5v5, 3 PP)
Nico Hischier - 3 goals, 12 assists - 15 points (11 5v5, 4 PP)

The fact that this isn't 50/50 or in Marner's favour due to his longer track record is telling about this site's bias against Leafs players.

AGES???

 

[Brobust]

Hischier is two years younger...

Marner is smaller and the fact that he was kept out of the NHL for his D+1 year isn't his fault.

 

[AD1066]

First 20 games

Mitch Marner - 7 goals, 9 assists - 16 points (13 5v5, 3 PP)
Nico Hischier - 3 goals, 12 assists - 15 points (11 5v5, 4 PP)

The fact that this isn't 50/50 or in Marner's favour due to his longer track record is telling about this site's bias against Leafs players.

Poll question is who will be the better offensive player-- maybe people genuinely prefer the younger, taller, faster player who made the NHL in his D+1 season.

 

[bsu]

Marner is smaller and the fact that he was kept out of the NHL for his D+1 year isn't his fault.

Which is probably some of the reason everyone is picking Hischier other than Toronto fans most likely....

 

[Snippit]

Marner is smaller and the fact that he was kept out of the NHL for his D+1 year isn't his fault.

This is possibly one of the worst arguments I've ever heard.

So because Marner is smaller than Hischier means you can directly compare a player in his D+3 with a player in his D+1?

Then proceed to call the rest of the board biased.

I've seen some very interesting claims from Toronto fans in the past several days...

 

[DFF]

First 20 games

Mitch Marner - 7 goals, 9 assists - 16 points (13 5v5, 3 PP)
Nico Hischier - 3 goals, 12 assists - 15 points (11 5v5, 4 PP)

The fact that this isn't 50/50 or in Marner's favour due to his longer track record is telling about this site's bias against Leafs players.

It's the other way around. The board is biased FOR the Leafs

Marner wasnt able to do what Hischier is doing at the same age. The fact that he put the same numbers while 2 yrs younger should put this poll 100% in his favor

 

[Scorcho]

Marner is smaller and the fact that he was kept out of the NHL for his D+1 year isn't his fault.

Yes...it is, he could have played his way onto the roster in training camp.

hell, even jesper bratt did that in his D+1

 

[DFAC]

Nico but it's close

 

[CanadienShark]

marner's good, nico's better,i'm gay, stats are bull**** if you know how easy it is to manipulate them, et cetera, et cetera

Huh?

 

[sparxx87]

Huh?

Wouldn’t you be happy too?

 

[Iapyi]

It's the other way around. The board is biased FOR the Leafs

Marner wasnt able to do what Hischier is doing at the same age. The fact that he put the same numbers while 2 yrs younger should put this poll 100% in his favor

no. the maple leafs have the most fans overall but there are far more fans when combining all the rest of the teams in the league.

there is a clear cut bias against the leafs, similar to the abuse many players take just because they are canadian,

 

[CanadienShark]

Wouldn’t you be happy too?

I'm just merely confused about why that was posted.

 

[BruinLVGA]

no. the maple leafs have the most fans overall but there are far more fans when combining all the rest of the teams in the league.

there is a clear cut bias against the leafs, similar to the abuse many players take just because they are canadian,

Pure persecution complex, right here.

 

[Yasuo]

When it was Ehlers vs Marner age was brought up by Leafs fans but when the other guy is 2 years younger it doesn't matter ?

 

[Scorcho]

Huh?

just stating facts

 

[VoluntaryDom]

Yes...it is, he could have played his way onto the roster in training camp.

hell, even jesper bratt did that in his D+1

that was his +2

 

[flamesforcup]

Lol. When Leafs lose a poll Leafs fans start claiming a bias against them. How insecure. The only bias is for the Leafs since they have so much fans and they swarm anyone who doesnt agree with them.

 

[Frosty415]

First 20 games

Mitch Marner - 7 goals, 9 assists - 16 points (13 5v5, 3 PP)
Nico Hischier - 3 goals, 12 assists - 15 points (11 5v5, 4 PP)

The fact that this isn't 50/50 or in Marner's favour due to his longer track record is telling about this site's bias against Leafs players.

Why do some Leaf fans always act like the victim?

It's sad. Please stop it does not help the stigma.

 

[Iapyi]

Pure persecution complex, right here.

lol. facts are facts.

 

[Scorcho]

that was his +2

you're right, probably makes more sense to compare bratt to marner instead of nico.

 

[snipes]

First 20 games

Mitch Marner - 7 goals, 9 assists - 16 points (13 5v5, 3 PP)
Nico Hischier - 3 goals, 12 assists - 15 points (11 5v5, 4 PP)

The fact that this isn't 50/50 or in Marner's favour due to his longer track record is telling about this site's bias against Leafs players.

Or Hischier doing it younger is more impressive.

 

[Lampedampe]

First 20 games

Mitch Marner - 7 goals, 9 assists - 16 points (13 5v5, 3 PP)
Nico Hischier - 3 goals, 12 assists - 15 points (11 5v5, 4 PP)

The fact that this isn't 50/50 or in Marner's favour due to his longer track record is telling about this site's bias against Leafs players.

The poll looks pretty even to me, why are you complaining?

 

[7even]

Offensive upside? Should be a too close to call option. I think both will max out at 80-85.